Yes, really.
Grace is a nice soothing song which would fit on MDH soundtrack. Awfully weak U2 closer though. It doesn't help that after Wild honey they completely aborted the pop/joy song collection intentions.
Well, to me Grace closes the album in the same way as Mothers in TJT, it's kinda sad, but makes me feel relaxed. (Not talking bout lyrics here, the subject is way too different to compare.)
I think ATYCLB 7-11<<HTDAAB 7-11 but ATYCLB 1-6>>>>>>HTDAAB 1-6
ATYCLB 1-6 is one of the best six song sequences in U2 history, up there with TJT in my book.
I really like the more balanced original tracklisting. Wasn't it The Edge who lobbied for the tracklist as it was on the final album? Strange stuff...
Hmmm...hard to say....but HTDAAB 1-6 has ABOY. So, yeah...it loses
Yeah, I guess it was Edge...but actually I have no problem with the actual tracklisting. It starts happy and poppy and as it goes it gets more darker and sad. As said above, I love the way Grace closes the album. To me, albuns must close with an quieter, slow song or an "epic" song. That's why I think Yahweh as a closer feels anti-climatic.