alanah
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
I just voted on Electrical Storm. 
New U2.com subscriber gift known... sort of.
- Thread starter Popmartijn
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
- Status
alanah
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
I just wish I could vote for North Star and Mercy. Saw them both live and I think they'd make a fantastic addition to a 360 live CD.
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
so do we know for sure that the top 22 tracks will be released on the double album, or is that just speculation?
also, will it be remastered?
also, will it be remastered?
alanah
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
Yeah, according to U2.com will be released only 22 tracks on the CD..
all the tracks have previews that do appear to have received a full on studio treatment.
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
oh they have previews? that's cool. i can't see them because i'm not a paying member.
Roland of Gilead
Gunslinger
If they're really smart (and in a good mood), the remaining 24 tracks not making the cut will get a download option by using a code that comes in the mail with the cd. 
Outsider
Refugee
Roland of Gilead said:If they're really smart (and in a good mood), the remaining 24 tracks not making the cut will get a download option by using a code that comes in the mail with the cd.
That'd be very cool. Probably Too cool . I'll be bummed if HMTMKMKM doesn't make the cut
flukeson
The Fly
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2011
- Messages
- 44
i cant wait for this to come out
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
i cant wait for this to come out
give it a couple years.
really though, i'm still a little skeptical that we'll actually see the top 22 voted tracks. part of it is that i'm not a paying member so i don't think i'm able to actually see the voting process, but i still have a strange feeling that we'll get a standard setlist with a couple of goodies thrown in from the voting results.
if i'm completely off base with my worries, please let me know as i haven't really dug into this and can't see a lot because i don't pay U2.com.
This is really cool. I'm tempted to renew my U2.com membership.
I wish this would happen for Vertigo, too. We have so many fantastic bootlegs from 360, but Vertigo isn't as good for bootlegs. It would be *amazing* to get Vertigo's version of Discothèque in soundboard quality.
I wish this would happen for Vertigo, too. We have so many fantastic bootlegs from 360, but Vertigo isn't as good for bootlegs. It would be *amazing* to get Vertigo's version of Discothèque in soundboard quality.
Outsider
Refugee
digitize said:
I agree
OP
OP
Popmartijn
Blue Crack Supplier
I think that Streets is the essential U2 live song and needs to be on it for that reason. Even though there are already several versions available.
And I don't care about Ultra Violet so I didn't include it (though I now realise there isn't an official live version (on CD) of that song yet).
Nick66
Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
Really? I think there's some fantastic Vertigo bootlegs (from a quality standpoint, I'm not big on that tour)...have you checked out any of the South America radio broadcasts like Sao Paulo or Buenos Aires? Granted, neither has Discothèque, but the quality on those recordings is fantastic (well, except the presenter's annoying habit of announcing the name of each song before it's played...you know, like Bono used to do.
)Those are some of the performances U23D was taken from and they're excellent.
powerhour24
ONE love, blood, life
Unknown Caller, HMTMKMKM and Your Blue Room need to make the cut!!! 
Also, Boots rocked so much in person, it'd be a shame for it not to be included.
I want to say songs that weren't indicative of a big stretch of the tour shouldn't be there (barring ES given those few instances are the only times it's even been played) but I can't totally get behind that because of how awesome Out of Control and One Tree Hill sounded when they were played.
Also, Boots rocked so much in person, it'd be a shame for it not to be included.
I want to say songs that weren't indicative of a big stretch of the tour shouldn't be there (barring ES given those few instances are the only times it's even been played) but I can't totally get behind that because of how awesome Out of Control and One Tree Hill sounded when they were played.
powerhour24
ONE love, blood, life
Oh, and shame on people for not voting for Return of the Stingray guitar, since we'll probably never see it again!
Outsider
Refugee
powerhour24 said:Unknown Caller, HMTMKMKM and Your Blue Room need to make the cut!!!
Also, Boots rocked so much in person, it'd be a shame for it not to be included.
Haha I was about to comment on the lack of UC love!
I'm happy Zooropa and TUF seem safe. If most of the NLOTH songs make it then maybe Bono will feel a bit more relevant. Ha
Finally a big hit for U2.com. Congratulations for this great gift!!!
I do not understand why people vote for the songs we already have a dozen of times like 'Where the streets' , 'Still haven't found'and 'Mysterious ways'. Why are 'Your blue room', 'Stingray' and 'Spanish eyes' so low in the list??
I don't want another big hits cd!!
I do not understand why people vote for the songs we already have a dozen of times like 'Where the streets' , 'Still haven't found'and 'Mysterious ways'. Why are 'Your blue room', 'Stingray' and 'Spanish eyes' so low in the list??
I don't want another big hits cd!!
Really? I think there's some fantastic Vertigo bootlegs (from a quality standpoint, I'm not big on that tour)...have you checked out any of the South America radio broadcasts like Sao Paulo or Buenos Aires? Granted, neither has Discothèque, but the quality on those recordings is fantastic (well, except the presenter's annoying habit of announcing the name of each song before it's played...you know, like Bono used to do.
Those are some of the performances U23D was taken from and they're excellent.
I've listened to Buenos Aires and Sao Paulo, and I actually don't like how they sound at all. They're clear, but there's something about the mix that I really don't like. I think I was probably just thinking about how much I would have liked to hear soundboard versions of Disco and electric Wild Horses.
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
i hate to ask again, but does U2.com specifically say anywhere that the top 22 voted tracks will be the ones that make the cd?
trojanchick99
Rock n' Roll Doggie FOB
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
hmmm.....so i would say that it leads you to believe that the top 22 voted tracks will be chosen, but it doesn't specifically say so.
i'm still a little concerned that U2.com will pull a fast one on everyone and give us a standard setlist with 1 or 2 deep cuts.
i'm still a little concerned that U2.com will pull a fast one on everyone and give us a standard setlist with 1 or 2 deep cuts.
Outsider
Refugee
Ooh it Doesn't say the top 22. If they're gonna pull a fast one on the final listing i hope it's somewhat believable
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
yep. i mean, they could easily take their top hits and then sprinkle in the top 5 votes rarities and then proclaim that "your voices have been heard".
Galeongirl
Galeonbroad
Don't be putting ideas into their heads Mikal. Knowing U2.com they'd pick it up and do it.
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
i know, i feel like i'm being the Nick66 of this thread, lol!
if U2 didn't have a history of screwing up, i would safely assume that the top 22 votes make the live album. but they've messed up so many times that it wouldn't surprise me if we're all shell shocked when the final tracklisting comes out and IALW, Elevation and Stuck are on it.
zoopop
Rock n' Roll Doggie
Can we get an update on the voting?
- Status
