I have a feeling that Heads On Sticks, paxetaurora and I have very similar CD collections.
Every time you guys post about the bands you like, I can't agree more.
I was going to mention Cardigans especially, they are awesome. But also Lucinda Williams, Better Than Ezra, and N.E.R.D.
Also one of my favorite bands is Fountains of Wayne. They also had just one hit, but they are incredible. They are the pop masters in my opinion. If you don't own Utopia Parkway or Welcome Interstate Managers, you really need to check em out. Oh hell, their first album is really good too.
Also, The Pernice Brothers. One of the best bands I have heard in a looooooooong time. And they are off the radar.