Ax, you said the other day you were at a Boston Vertigo show, right? Speaking of things I may have misread...
My issue with putting Hawkmoon first (and I think it's a fantastic song), is that it's a little dark and grandiose compared to the rest of the album. For the most part, this is a looser, less atmospheric collection of recordings compared to JT, and I feel like the opening should reflect that.
Which is why I think Desire works best in the #1 slot.
Yep, I went to the three Boston shows in May 2005.
Stay on it you guys. Those Southern Hemispherians will have another drunken listening party and Cobbler will start a new thread.
Stay on it you guys. Those Southern Hemispherians will have another drunken listening party and Cobbler will start a new thread.
It's too bad I wasn't in your nosebleed section for the 1 I went to, the people where I was were really lame. Aside from The Electric Co, looking at the setlist I don't even remember half the good songs being played that they apparently did. They did The Fly and I have no memory of it whatsoever, and I loved that song at the time. I remember being bored as fuck for pretty much the whole show, blaming Springsteen for spoiling me (as I'd gone to see him do a kickass solo devils & dust tour show a week earlier) by playing such a ridiculous setlist for about an hour longer than U2. I still haven't forgiven Bono for rambling on about Africa over the intro to streets, effectively ruining what I'd expected would be an impossible song to ruin.
Anyway, I've bitched about how disappointed I was in that show numerous times before, I just thought it was interesting reading your post the other day about how great RTSS was, at a show I was fucking at, and it wasn't even memorable to me. And that song is one of the few U2 songs I still consider to be great.
... Sorry for another post but a concert of just Edge singing would be the greatest thing theyve done in years. Id love to hear that.
Time to get drinking, lads!
Yeah I think I recall you posting in the past about your disappointment with the show. For me night one was definitely the weakest of the three shows - I can't pick which I prefer out of nights two and three, they were both amazing. But I still enjoyed the gig a whole lot, especially that RTSS moment. I couldn't believe my whole nosebleed section stood the whole night, but I think that was partly because it was chock-full of U2.com members who got screwed in the presale shambles. Of course, I was a hyper nutty fan then and probably would've enjoyed almost anything, but it was definitely a better show than most of what I saw when they finally came down here in 2006, or any of those bloody 360 shows. (Still grumpy the only decent 360 setlists were in 2011 after my run was over and I was no longer obsessed enough to fly to North America again).
I remember that whole trip really well. I've no particularly strong plans to return to the States, but if I ever do, I need to spend more time in Boston. Had a great week there.
Yep, I went to the three Boston shows in May 2005.
Not sure how I wasn't aware of it at the time and didn't arrange to meet you to say hello. (Attended 2 of those shows)
Hot take:
I don't think Edge's singing voice is all that great. I mean, he's great for backing vocals. Wouldn't want to hear him sing more than parts of a song (Miracle Drug, Stuck, etc). Van Dieman's Land? Meh. Too nasal.
.... I'll show myself out.
I later discovered a couple of other Interferencers saw me, though I didn't see them. Where were you at those shows? Aside from the nosebleed adventures on night 1, for nights 2 and 3 I won the GA lottery and found myself right in front of Edge both times.
On the second night I went with a friend and we had signs for One Tree Hill and 11 O'clock Tick Tock. Edge just smiled and shook his head.
And my axe. His voice is pleasant enough but, yeah, no need for him to sing more than one song, maybe, per night. I like Bono's voice, go figure.
Did CK ever get a pic of Adam on his back?
Sent from my iPhone using U2 Interference