Absolute Worst Song Off HTDAAB: What is it for you and why?

[starsgoblue]

oohhhh, maybe just one
touching doesnt count as going all the way
and i already bought the album.....
which one is the greatest for putting me in a totally bono crazed fever?

Which one should I send her, guys?

 

[u2bonogirl]

i feel so bad
bless me father for i have sinned

 

[starsgoblue]

Come on! You changed your mind already....this whole guilt thing is really self-flagellating Tara...

Do you still want one or not?

 

[U2_Guy]

Jick...

Go back worship ATYCLB man... A negative post today?? Come on!

The only so so track here is OSC which is even then better than POE and Grace.

 

[u2bonogirl]

ummm
yes
I would make a good catholic wouldnt i

 

[starsgoblue]

TARA! I'm dissapointed in you....why are you not listening? Do you think it would ruin the 23rd??

 

[u2bonogirl]

ummm
yes
I would make a good catholic wouldnt i

*was referring to guilt, not doing bad things*

 

[jick]

Ok, now I've made up my mind -- sort of. The worst song for me is a toss-up between LAPOE or Man And Woman - but worst is relative. These two are still very strong songs but I'm just saying there are 9 other stronger tracks in the album.

Vertigo, Miracle Drug, City Of Blinding Lights, and SYCMIOYO are brilliant tracks. I hope I don't ruffle some feathers here but I honestly think this album could be better than ATYCLB.

Cheers,

J

 

[starsgoblue]

You're going to yell and scream at me on the 23rd saying, "Why did you hear this angel's symphony and let me not listen to it?!"

 

[u2bonogirl]

TARA! I'm dissapointed in you....why are you not listening? Do you think it would ruin the 23rd??

when i said yes i meant i wanted to hear a song, babe
but i still feel naughty

 

[starsgoblue]

Ok, now I've made up my mind -- sort of. The worst song for me is a toss-up between LAPOE or Man And Woman - but worst is relative. These two are still very strong songs but I'm just saying there are 9 other stronger tracks in the album.

Hey you, get off my cloud!!


What I have to say about anyone actually poo-pooing this diamond of an album on the day my ears were blessed to hear it for the first time:

 

[starsgoblue]

when i said yes i meant i wanted to hear a song, babe
but i still feel naughty

Why would you feel naughty....that's silliness.

 

[as you wish16]

For me it would be One Step Closer. I think it's too repetitive and doesn't actually "go anywhere" when compared to the rest of the album.

 

[Axver]

I hope I don't ruffle some feathers here but I honestly think this album could be better than ATYCLB.

I think the general consensus on the board right now is that Hut Dab makes ATYCLB look pretty poor.

 

[ramblin rose]

For me it would be One Step Closer. I think it's too repetitive and doesn't actually "go anywhere" when compared to the rest of the album.

I'll have to agree with you. I haven't figured this one out yet.

 

[u2bonogirl]

i cant wait to hear it if its that much better than ATYCLB
at first i didnt even like the album and then it grew on me after a while
it was such sissy rock to me to begin with..you know?
from what i hear the new album is not sissy rock

 

[JOFO]

Ok, now I've made up my mind -- sort of. The worst song for me is a toss-up between LAPOE or Man And Woman - J

whoever thinks LAPOE is crap doesn't know what u2 is all about; simple as that.

 

[grbounds]

whoever thinks LAPOE is crap doesn't know what u2 is all about; simple as that.

thats kind of provincial. i dont like LAPOE very much either, but im pretty sure i know what U2 are all about, being a fan for a decade now....

 

[dlihcraw]

"Vertigo" because it sounds nothing like the rest of the album! However, “Vertigo” is anything but a bad song!

I’m ecstatic, more than satisfied. U2 are playing their best music, and they are the best. As a fan, I could have asked for nothing better. As a fan, I would have settled for much less!

Favourite song: “A Man And A Woman”

 

[JOFO]

thats kind of provincial. i dont like LAPOE very much either, but im pretty sure i know what U2 are all about, being a fan for a decade now....

well, I got 20 years pal.

anyway, I'm just giving some props to my pal jick.
if you wanna start some shit, go ahead.

 

[Cutters10C]

I can't say that there is a single song I would describe as weak, but the songs I have listened to the least are Man and a Woman and One Step Closer, but that is mostly because I can't stop listening to Miracle Drug, COBL, and Original of the Species and the rest of the album.

 

[bcrt2000]

i think they u2 should make a song called the "digital terrorist" dedicated to jick

just kidding

 

[grbounds]

well, I got 20 years pal.

anyway, I'm just giving some props to my pal jick.
if you wanna start some shit, go ahead.

 

[whitehead]

Sorry....I just saw "Contradiction is balance" on Axver's post....carry on.

 

[whitehead]

i cant wait to hear it if its that much better than ATYCLB
at first i didnt even like the album and then it grew on me after a while
it was such sissy rock to me to begin with..you know?
from what i hear the new album is not sissy rock

Just to warn you...There are some songs on here that, if you are a guy, you might feel uncomfortable listnening to alone with another guy! I don't know if that is your definition of "sissy rock" or not though. There are definitely some ATYCLB moments.

Great album nonetheless!

 

[neutral]

Just to warn you...There are some songs on here that, if you are a guy, you might feel uncomfortable listnening to alone with another guy!!

 

[whitehead]

Neutral: For example, "A Man and a Woman."

 

[Seeking Adam]

I gotta take a dump

 

[david]

I thought "sissy rock" was a term coined soley to describe that "Rock" album Aaron Carter made a couple years ago that every has probably forgotten about already.

 

[grbounds]

I thought "sissy rock" was a term coined soley to describe that "Rock" album Aaron Carter made a couple years ago that every has probably forgotten about already.

but i love aaron carter!