dan_smee
ONE love, blood, life
Anyone got a voting update?
Would be shattered if it was just Pride and Boots all over the place
Would be shattered if it was just Pride and Boots all over the place
New U2.com subscriber gift known... sort of.
- Thread starter Popmartijn
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
- Status
corianderstem
Blue Crack Distributor
Let's not waste any good worrying on this.
nirniva
Rock n' Roll Doggie Band-aid
I've been wanting another proper U2 live album for a while now...this is a good idea!
Now, here's hoping for a vinyl version a la Artificial Horizon...
God Part III
Rock n' Roll Doggie Band-aid
Boy Falls From The Sky?
Anyone?
It's such a good idea, but if they keep Every Breaking Wave and Boy Falls From The Sky off this thing, I'll be so disappointed. Looks like they will, too
Anyone?
It's such a good idea, but if they keep Every Breaking Wave and Boy Falls From The Sky off this thing, I'll be so disappointed. Looks like they will, too
dan_smee
ONE love, blood, life
Boy Falls From The Sky?
Anyone?
It's such a good idea, but if they keep Every Breaking Wave and Boy Falls From The Sky off this thing, I'll be so disappointed. Looks like they will, too
Just had a thought re North Star and EBW... Perhaps they really are planning on releasing an album next year, and these will be on it, so they want to keep them away from an official release for this one?
OP
OP
Popmartijn
Blue Crack Supplier
1. Ultra Violet (Light My Way) 3.78%
2. Bad 3.69%
3. Even Better Than The Real Thing 3.5%
4. Where The Streets Have No Name 3.35%
5. Zooropa 3.22%
6. Magnificent 3.09%
7. Moment of Surrender 2.97%
8. The Fly 2.94%
9. Out Of Control 2.93%
10. The Unforgettable Fire 2.84%
11. Until The End Of The World 2.78%
12. One Tree Hill 2.68%
13. One 2.6%
14. No Line On the Horizon 2.49%
15. With Or Without You 2.46%
16. All I Want Is You/Love Rescue Me 2.43%
17. 40 2.41%
18. Stay (Faraway, So Close!) 2.37%
19. Beautiful Day 2.37%
20. Breathe 2.37%
21. City Of Blinding Lights 2.33%
22. Electrical Storm 2.26%
23. I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight (Remix) 2.18%
24. I Still Haven’t Found What I’m looking For 2.15%
25. Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 2.13%
OP
OP
Popmartijn
Blue Crack Supplier
Boy Falls From The Sky?
Anyone?
It's such a good idea, but if they keep Every Breaking Wave and Boy Falls From The Sky off this thing, I'll be so disappointed. Looks like they will, too
You can't vote for them so they won't be on it.
mirrorballman
Refugee
The top 22 look fine for now, but who votes for WOWY, BD and/or One???? We have those on all possible DVD's and CD's! Push in the rarities, MOTD, Spanish Eyes, etc!
OP
OP
Popmartijn
Blue Crack Supplier
I think these would be my choices (and I tried to create some sort of a U2 360 setlist for it):
1 Breathe
2 No Line On the Horizon
3 Out Of Control
4 Return Of The Stingray Guitar
5 Even Better Than The Real Thing
6 The Fly
7 Electrical Storm
8 All I Want Is You/Love Rescue Me
9 Mothers Of The Disappeared
10 Bad
11 The Unforgettable Fire
12 Unknown Caller
13 Your Blue Room
14 Zooropa
15 I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight (Remix)
16 Scarlet
17 One Tree Hill
18 Where The Streets Have No Name
19 Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me
20 Spanish Eyes
21 Moment of Surrender
22 “40”
I'm holding out voting for a while to see if other tracks need extra support.
1 Breathe
2 No Line On the Horizon
3 Out Of Control
4 Return Of The Stingray Guitar
5 Even Better Than The Real Thing
6 The Fly
7 Electrical Storm
8 All I Want Is You/Love Rescue Me
9 Mothers Of The Disappeared
10 Bad
11 The Unforgettable Fire
12 Unknown Caller
13 Your Blue Room
14 Zooropa
15 I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight (Remix)
16 Scarlet
17 One Tree Hill
18 Where The Streets Have No Name
19 Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me
20 Spanish Eyes
21 Moment of Surrender
22 “40”
I'm holding out voting for a while to see if other tracks need extra support.
chocky
Refugee
^ almost exactly what I picked - except I left off Streets (don't really need ANOTHER version of that) and went for UV instead.
mirrorballman
Refugee
This.
Picked 99.9% the same things, left out Streets for the same reason and have UV in there as well.
Also left out the Crazy mix (we have the Dublin version on the Artificial Horizon and I'm sure they'll just use the same version), can't remember what I added instead of it though.
chocky
Refugee
On most of the mp3 files on U2.com they have the location of the recording (40=London, Your Blue Room=NY, GOYB=Boston, Zooropa=Baltimore, AIWIY/Rescue=Sydney, Spanish Eyes=San Sebastien, Pride=Gelsenkirchen, Real Thing=Mexico, Stingray=Vienna, Scarlet=Melbourne etc). Crazy mix location isn't shown, but you're probably right with Dublin. Desire just has the date shown as 050809.
dan_smee
ONE love, blood, life
mp3 files on U2.com Dave, say WHAT?
chocky
Refugee
They're only 45 second samples of the tracks we can choose from.
Australia gets a good selection
All I Want is You / Love Rescue Me - Sydney
Moment of Surrender - Perth
Scarlet - Melbourne
and One Tree Hill = Auckland (which is almost Australia, except during the World Cup!)
I guess it's safe to assume they have soundboards of all their concerts.
By the way, the mp3s sound great
dan_smee
ONE love, blood, life
Hope someone rips them and posts them somewhere... regretting letting my membership lapse now!
You went to the 2nd sydney show didn't you? Be good to have a song from a show we were at! Same with Kite from Vertigo on the WITS single
You went to the 2nd sydney show didn't you? Be good to have a song from a show we were at! Same with Kite from Vertigo on the WITS single
chocky
Refugee
Yeah I went to both Sydney shows. I was also there for Kite (WITS single) and also at Sydney Football Stadium for the taping of the Zoomerang 1993 video.
When you play the mp3 samples, they leave a download file in your temporary internet files (there's probably a technical term for that right?). Anyway, I've simply copied them to iTunes which is where I can see the info re locations.
dan_smee
ONE love, blood, life
Are they only available to subscribers?
chocky
Refugee
yes
Galeongirl
Galeonbroad
Wow. I'm REALLY happy about this. Finally a gift worth renewing for! 
I think the most brilliant thing is that only subscribers are allowed to vote. That means only people crazy enough to shell out cash for a membership vote. AKA no casual fans. So that gives us a higher chance of getting songs like Zooropa, The Fly and HMTMKMKM.
Please Note: Voting is open to current U2.com Subscribers - or anyone who subscribes/resubscribes during the voting period. One vote per subscriber. Voting closes on DECEMBER 2ND.
You can still renew and vote.
I think the most brilliant thing is that only subscribers are allowed to vote. That means only people crazy enough to shell out cash for a membership vote. AKA no casual fans. So that gives us a higher chance of getting songs like Zooropa, The Fly and HMTMKMKM.
Please Note: Voting is open to current U2.com Subscribers - or anyone who subscribes/resubscribes during the voting period. One vote per subscriber. Voting closes on DECEMBER 2ND.
You can still renew and vote.
Galeongirl
Galeonbroad
Here's an updated list of how the voting is right now:
Love how almost all of their 'acoustic' songs are dead last. With Stay excluded.
Love how almost all of their 'acoustic' songs are dead last. With Stay excluded.
bonocomet
Blue Crack Distributor
This is a great gift!
djerdap
Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2004
- Messages
- 7,605
First of all, finally a pretty cool idea.
I love the fact that the shitty Crazy Tonight remix is not making the cut as of now (it could get up there though), but I hope Hold Me, Thrill Me... gets to be in the top 22.
I love the fact that the shitty Crazy Tonight remix is not making the cut as of now (it could get up there though), but I hope Hold Me, Thrill Me... gets to be in the top 22.
Globo14
Refugee
Good looking list as of now. HMTMyadayada needs to get up there tho.
Is it just picking songs, or is it by setlist position? For example, can you only vote for EBTTRT, Breathe, Stingray Guitar in the first spot?
Is it just picking songs, or is it by setlist position? For example, can you only vote for EBTTRT, Breathe, Stingray Guitar in the first spot?
honestly... this has nothing to do with my dislike of the crazy remix... but we already have a version of it that was released. we don't need another one.
same goes for moment of surrender. we already have a fantastic version. let's get stuff we don't have.
who's with me?
nobody?
same goes for moment of surrender. we already have a fantastic version. let's get stuff we don't have.
who's with me?
nobody?
stealthboy
War Child
I just wish I could vote for North Star and Mercy. Saw them both live and I think they'd make a fantastic addition to a 360 live CD. I really don't want it to turn into a 'best of' collection. 
OP
OP
Popmartijn
Blue Crack Supplier
How can you see the location of the recordings? I can only click on the songs and then a sample plays in my browser. It doesn't say where the recordings are from.
(And how can "40" be from London, it wasn't played there!)
here's an idea... how about they just give us all the tracks and release them to us online, since they obviously already put the work in to produce the tracks in the studio... why let the work on the other tracks go to waste? 
LadySpinHead
Refugee
I've been holding out on subscribing to wait and see what the gift would be- didn't have much desire for Duals and the last time I signed up a couple of years ago I never got Artificial Horizon because we were in the middle of moving and it was probably sent to my old address and never forwarded. This sounds worth trying again.
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
people need to step up the voting on Electrical Storm!
glad U2.com is posting the voting results. adds some credibility. they could have easily hidden the voting results and given us a standard setlist.
glad U2.com is posting the voting results. adds some credibility. they could have easily hidden the voting results and given us a standard setlist.
- Status
