we already did. guess what won?IrishDawg said:Are we going to have survivor for the best U2 song?
we already did. guess what won?IrishDawg said:Are we going to have survivor for the best U2 song?
KhanadaRhodes said:
we already did. guess what won?
Axver said:I'd actually like to see a Survivor for the WORST song, as I don't think that's so clear-cut. The Refugee, Red Light, 4th Of July, Love Rescue Me, Babyface, Some Days Are Better Than Others, Miami, Peace On Earth, Grace, et cetera - I can see all of them battling it out and I don't think the winner would be that obvious.
Originally posted by IrishDawg
Luminous Times And Walk to The Water don't strike me as decent b-sides, but Lady With The Spinning Head and Night and Day are some of my favorite b-sides.
KhanadaRhodes said:shit, maybe i'm gonna have to do the worst song survivor since no one else is stepping up to the plate. (yeah, like i HAVE to or something.)
i guess after this is all done i'll make a sticky thread and ask people for their input on what songs to include.
Axver said:In my opinion:
Luminous Times > With Or Without You > Walk To The Water > Lady With The Spinning Head > One > uncreative covers.
I would much rather listen to a song that U2 have created and written themselves rather than simply lifting from someone else. As with every rule, there is an exception, but not for the One single. I'm talking about Dancing Barefoot, which you people kicked off FIRST, and the Lovetown versions of All Along The Watchtower, which obviously never had a chance.
It seems some people are just extremely emotionally attached to One and can't bring themselves to vote against it and have let vastly superior single collections fall by the wayside.
yeah, pretty much everything you said was how we did the best song survivor series. each album was a category, and then all the b-sides were another category; covers weren't included.TheRooster said:I think we should just go album by album. You list all the songs including b-sides and then vote for the one you like the most.
KhanadaRhodes said:
maybe we should have a survivor series on what to do for the next survivor series!!
TheRooster said:
Brilliant! I love it.