(02-06-2003) Ten reasons U2 belongs in the Rock Hall - Cleveland Scene

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

HelloAngel

ONE love, blood, life
Joined
Sep 22, 2001
Messages
14,534
Location
new york city
http://www.clevescene.com/

Pro Bono
Ten reasons U2 belongs in the Rock Hall.
BY MICHAEL GALLUCCI





With the February 9 opening of In the Name of Love: Two Decades of U2 at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum, the Irish quartet is finally getting a corner to claim as its very own within the coveted corridors. Not that Bono and the boys really need the Rock Hall -- which is gathering two decades of memorabilia, such as the Edge's studded jeans, the leather jacket last seen on Bono at Super Bowl XXXVI, and various promotional materials -- to present them with such an honor. We already know that U2 is one of the greatest bands in the world.

So while you contemplate the Stetson that Bono wore during The Joshua Tree tour and production notes by producer Daniel Lanois, consider what secured the group this artifact-packed exhibit in the first place: the music. Below, U2's greatest hits -- the perfect soundtrack to your Rock Hall gawk.

1. "Beautiful Day" -- When it was released in 2000, it sounded big, gorgeous, and anthemic. It's even more so today.

2. All That You Can't Leave Behind -- There's a resonance to this, U2's greatest album. It's simultaneously elated and weary. And aware of every note being played.

3. Achtung Baby -- They've reinvented themselves so many times since this 1991 outing that it's easy to forget just how un-U2-like it originally sounded. It's when they first proved they wanted to do more than just save the world.

4. The Joshua Tree -- The 1987 album that elevated the band from cult status to rock stars. The best of it -- "With or Without You," "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" -- still matters.

5. Zooropa -- It's the most overlooked of the top albums, an experimental tour de force that makes room for everything from the Edge reciting a mantra to Johnny Cash chiming in.

6. War -- This 1983 opus sounds a little naive 20 years later. But everything U2 would become -- the ringing guitars, the fist-in-the-air sloganeering -- forms here.

7. "Pride (In the Name of Love)" -- A warm and angry tribute to Martin Luther King Jr., it's the boys' first great single (from the murky The Unforgettable Fire). Overly earnest, but they mean each and every word of it.

8. "One" -- It implies anything you want it to -- a death march for an AIDS victim, a spiritual call for solidarity, the gospel according to the prophet Bono. And that's the beauty of it.

9. "Walk On" -- Like "Beautiful Day," this moving song from All That You Can't Leave Behind takes on even more significance post-9-11.

10. "With or Without You" -- The Joshua Tree's finest song is among its most conventional. The slow build, the sweeping chorus, the redemption at the very center of its message -- classic U2, at the very moment they became classic.
 
skirkham2002 said:
Good points. But ATYCLB their "greatest album"? It is certainly among the best (in the top three certainly) but that it is the best is debatable.


I guess it's a "personal preference" issue. I'm not sure if I agree with that either. My favorite U2 album is AB.
 
Arg....I have to totally disagree with this list of 10 reasons. U2 was not suddenly made great in the last 2-10 years. Way too much credit given to the last album. If anything, U2 should be seen as FOUR different bands during their amazing career. Boy-War(1)Unforgettable Fire-Rattle and Hum(2)Achtung Baby-Pop(3)Leave Behind-????(4). Most bands don't ever change their sound, album from album. U2 has done it more times then I think a band of this calibur ever has and maintained sales close to the top.

But what about live performances?!? Not one mention in the article? Does that not count towards the Hall o Fame? If anything, U2 have created themselves more on the stage than they have in the studio.

And lastly, the songs that never have received air time on the radio throught the years comprise some of the best written music by U2. I can't how many times I've skipped right over New Year's Day to get to Drowning Man (ah, thank god we don't use vinyl any more..)
 
Good points. I am *amazed* that the guy doesn't mention the live shows. U2 have always been such a phenomenal live band! They still are! They have had several parts to their careers, not just one or two like most bands. Man, I call that greatness.
 
Personaly I really do think the past 2 years solidifies U2 as one of, if not the greatest band ever. What other band can you think of that completely de-constructed themselves, at the same time had thier biggest "failure," and then say that they are ready to be the best band again and do it after all those years! ATYCLB is just that. So many of my friends were amazed that they were able to come back and write an album like it after all that. I do think AB is their best piece of work, but ATYCLB is just testament to the pure magic that these four men bring:)

P.S. Beautiful Day is my favorite song ever!
 
gherman said:
Personaly I really do think the past 2 years solidifies U2 as one of, if not the greatest band ever. What other band can you think of that completely de-constructed themselves, at the same time had thier biggest "failure," and then say that they are ready to be the best band again and do it after all those years! ATYCLB is just that. So many of my friends were amazed that they were able to come back and write an album like it after all that. I do think AB is their best piece of work, but ATYCLB is just testament to the pure magic that these four men bring:)

P.S. Beautiful Day is my favorite song ever!


I agree 100%!!
 
i started to get a bit tired of hearing beautiful day all the time, but i listened to it with headphones on and it's fucking amazing

why did it take me that long to realise thaT?!?!?!?!
 
Back
Top Bottom