I didn't even share my thoughts on the movie as a whole. I kinda liked it. It has many flaws, but it was a pretty fun comic book movie. I'm a fan of the X-Men universe to begin with, so that helped. I grew up on the cartoon series. Anyway...
I actually enjoyed some of the attempts at being a campy, 1960s espionage movie. The whole globetrotting, multilingual, guns and mysterious briefcases thing. The idea of setting an X-Men movie in the 60s is, frankly, a fucking cool idea. It could have been executed better. The period isn't perfectly sold. But I'm also sure it could have been executed worse.
McAvoy is the best thing about the movie, for my money. I thought he was fantastic as Xavier. Very charming, funny, likable. And his chemistry with THE FASS! was strong.
Here's probably the biggest problem:
Had First Class not been bound by the continuity of the Singer films and been its own piece, I would have enjoyed it a lot more.
You hit the nail on the head there, LMP. Totally agree.
Why not just do a complete reboot? It spends too much time winking at those in the audience that have seen the Singer films. Some of the winks worked, most of them did not. I got a kick out of Jackman's "Go fuck yourself" cameo, but when Jennifer Lawrence turns into Rebecca Romijn? Nah. That was just stupid. And the way they went about naming the characters was silly, etc.
And the thing that bugged me the most (in regards to keeping the continuity with Singer's films) was what happened to Mystique at the end of the movie. I liked the relationship between McAvoy and Lawrence. It was established that they were childhood friends, best friends, and I liked that. Then she suddenly joins Magneto at the end. Why? Oh yeah, because Magneto and Mystique were pals in the Singer movies. Fuck that. It felt totally forced.
And in either of the two Singer movies, do Prof X and Mystique have any interaction whatsoever? I don't think so. But they were best friends since they were like 6? Fuck that.
Despite the many gripes...enjoyable. And I'd recommend it. I'm going to bed.