Up in the Air. Well-written, well-directed, decently-acted. I have some major issues with the last 10 min or so of the film. Without veering into spoiler territory, why in god's name would she give him her address? That makes no sense. Also, I'm not sure I like the documentary stuff wedged in there near the end, with the real-life fired people talking about their lives. It should have been strewn throughout the film a la Reds/When Harry Met Sally, or not at all. I also thought the scene with Sam Elliott seemed a bit too fantastical compared to the tone of the rest of the film. A little sloppy.
Also, I love Clooney, but five best perfs of the year? Really? I don't see what he did aside from play himself. This ain't no Michael Clayton, Solaris, O Brother, whatever. Many more worthy candidates this year. And I'm also not sure that Kendrick and Farmiga did Oscar-level work, as good as they both are.
What I REALLY enjoyed was Fantastic Mr. Fox. Pixar's Up is a fucking joke compared to this film. Creativity that goes beyond a musical montage scene at the beginning of the film. Such great work from everyone on the technical and vocal side. I loved the art direction/production design, a real shame this wasn't nominated. And the idea that Up's screenplay was nominated and this wasn't (especially as Fox would have been in the weak adapted category) is ridiculous.
Definitely in my Top 10.