OK here's the stats first:Categories are Passing Yds, Completion Percentage, Pass TD's, Td-Int ratio, Passer rating and SuperBowl/NFL titles:
Marino: 61,361 ,59.4% , 420 Td, 1.64 ratio, 86.4 rating, 0 titles
Montana: 40, 551, 63.2%, 273 TD, 1.96 ratio, 92.3 rating, 4 titles
Unitas; 40,239, 54.6%, 290 TD, 1.15 ratio, 78.2 rating, 2 titles
Graham: 13,499, 55.7%, 88TD, 0.94 ratio, 78.2 rating 3 titles
Tittle: 28,339, 55.5%, 203TD, 0.92 ratio, 73.6 rating, 0 titles
Starr: 24,718, 57.4%, 152TD, 1.10 ratio, 80.5 rating, 5 titles
Tarkenton: 47,003, 57.0%, 342TD, 1.29 ratio, 80.4 rating, 0 titles
Bradshaw: 27,989, 51.9%, 212TD, 1.01 ratio, 70.9 rating, 4 titles
Staubach: 22,700, 57.0%, 153TD, 1.40 ratio, 73.6 rating, 2 titles
Baugh: 21,886, 56.4%, 187TD, 0.92 ratio, 72.2 rating, 2 titles
Fouts: 43,040, 58.8%, 254TD, 1.05 ratio, 80.2 rating, 0 titles
Kelly: 35,467, 60.1%, 237TD, 1.35 ratio, 84.4 rating, 0 titles
Elway: 51,475, 56.9%, 300TD, 1.33 ratio, 79.9 rating, 2 titles
Favre: 48,806, 61.4%, 369TD, 1.66 ratio, 87.1 rating, 1 title
Now to rank (this'll take a few minutes), I'm gonna rank the first 5 categories on a 14-13-12...-2-1 sliding scale, and award 1 point per title to not handicap the Marino's of the world too much.