http://media.u2.com/flash/highlights/larryinstudio.swf
This is actually my favorite. I wonder if it is Moment of Surrender
This is actually my favorite. I wonder if it is Moment of Surrender
http://media.u2.com/flash/highlights/dallas.swf
Help > it's beautifull > what this song is supposed 2 be on the new Album??
thanx
http://media.u2.com/flash/highlights/larryinstudio.swf
This is actually my favorite. I wonder if it is Moment of Surrender
Secondly, the timing is 5:58, and the descriptions of "Winter" said it clocked around 6 minutes.
The rumor was that it was the song Winter because the Q review mentioned it started with a long beautiful strings intro. That clip isn't strings, its Edge's infinite guitar, but I can see how it would be confused for strings.
Not sure, but a great clip none the less.
Anyone else having trouble loading the very first clip on the list????
its the "...ng_april" clip. It doesn't load for me. What is it of?
What if «Porn» is... "Winter"?
First it says "(Prov)" after the title. It could indicate that it was only a provisional title.
Secondly, the timing is 5:58, and the descriptions of "Winter" said it clocked around 6 minutes.
If we think that these songs are definitely not finished by the time this table was filmed, "Winter" could not be the name of that song then and attributed after when Q and RS came.
Just a thought...
I hope that it isn't because I love the song title "Winter". It just seems so evocative. Either way..its cool, because at least we'd be getting the song. But in the end I'd bet that the song is actually "Tripoli" with a different title.
What ifthe video was recorded before the "Winter" ("new") title? We don't know exactly when "Winter" title came, nor when this video was recorded.
We know that "Tripoli" must be a late song, that is, one of the last songs that were probably written, composed and recorded.
The problem here is that... we don't have credible a timeline for these facts... eh eh
http://media.u2.com/flash/highlights/edgeback.swf
This is my favourite clip.
At 0.50 what is Edge playing? Magnificent?
Call me crazy, but I swear I can hear this as the rythm guitar part in beach clip 4.
And call me crazy again, but I'd bet money that 4 is Unknown Caller.
how much money and i'll pm you my PayPal account information.
Honestly, if you could prove me wrong, I would pay for that. Because then I would have a little more concrete information about the record than I do now.
Do you know what clip 4 is? Because I swear I can hear him sing "Unknown Caller." And the melody is so close to the chord changes in the edgeback video, I have to believe the go together.
Or I could be 100% wrong. Prove me wrong. I yearn for knowing.
Honestly, if you could prove me wrong, I would pay for that. Because then I would have a little more concrete information about the record than I do now.
Do you know what clip 4 is? Because I swear I can hear him sing "Unknown Caller." And the melody is so close to the chord changes in the edgeback video, I have to believe they go together.
Or I could be 100% wrong. Prove me wrong. I yearn for knowing.
Clip 4 is Magnificent. You can clearly hear Bono sing 'magnificent' at around 2:40 and 4:20 and I even think it is the word you here him sing as the clips starts. Unknown Caller is thought to be Clip 1.
Also, since I'm playing catchup here, the consensus is...?
Clip 1 Unknown Caller
Clip 2 Breath
Clip 3 Get On Your Boots
Clip 4 Magnificent
Just curious.
Clip 5? Is that the one where some Italian guy talks to his friends while he rubs the mic on his jacket?Yes.
And I was wondering what song Beach clip #5 would be...
Yes.
And I was wondering what song Beach clip #5 would be...
i think its no chance of being crazy tonight
the descriptions say that the song centres around the line ill go crazy if i dont go crazy tonihgt... Don't hear it in there once...
Its either a track not on the album, or id guess an early version of every breaking wave
i think its no chance of being crazy tonight
the descriptions say that the song centres around the line ill go crazy if i dont go crazy tonihgt... Don't hear it in there once...
I think it is crazy tonight as well.
in the first few seconds right after the wave fades out at 9 seconds I hear
"if I dont go Craaaaazy toooniiIIIiiiiiIIiight"
I do think that clip 5 is in fact Crazy Tonight, perhaps in an early stage, but still. Examine the faint lines of this sheet of paper that Bono donated to charity. It clearly says "I'll go crazy if I don't go..."( should be crazy tonight after that) right? Then the line below says something along the lines of ...is a mountain. The thicker scribble are lyrics for Breathe as decided upon in the past.
00:18, 00:27, 01:37 : "Mountain"
Then the most interesting part:
01:08: If I go crazy (long note) / We're going crazy (Edge backups)
Check that out and let me know if I need to do a check-up on my ears, please.