Rolling Stone: U2's best ...

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

last unicorn

Blue Crack Addict
Joined
May 5, 2006
Messages
19,427
Location
lost in poetry
... by the bands that love them

Great RS article: :)

U2's Best By the Bands That Love Them : Rolling Stone

Wayne Coyne, Taylor Swift, Pete Wentz and more artists weigh in on U2's greatest albums and songs

In Rolling Stone's new U2 cover story, Bono and Co. take us inside their troubled quest for a new sound and soul as they wrote and recorded No Line on the Horizon. We asked some of their contemporaries for their favorite songs and albums from the group's three-decade career — check out what Wayne Coyne, Duffy, Pete Wentz and Taylor Swift had to say, and share your own picks below, in our U2 album poll.

The Flaming Lips' Wayne Coyne
I have a favorite U2 song: "One." My favorite album is All That You Can't Leave Behind. There's something about Bono coming from this Irish family. I'm from a sort of Irish family. There's something about the way he sings about his family and friends and even the death of his father, even though "One" isn't about that. When my father was dying I listened to that song, it struck me. Later on I read about Bono's father dying. I understood his state of mind and related to it. It's a well-written song and he sings great. The Edge sings great. As hokey as it can be, there's something very powerful about the way Bono can get away with those big, overreaching kinds of songs.

Death Cab for Cutie's Ben Gibbard
War from start to finish is unbelievable, the songs are amazing, but the production — it's such a large-sounding record that when you break it apart. There aren't a lot of overdubs, not a lot of [what the band embraced] when U2 moved into some flashier stages in the late '80s and '90s. That's my favorite record by them because it shows exactly what they are really great at doing. All the songs are there. They weren't so self-aware. The same way as R.E.M.'s Murmur.

Taylor Swift
I'm a huge U2 fan. "Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own" is my favorite. I actually hadn't heard it and really paid attention to it until I saw it in their 3D movie and I almost started crying because it moved me so much. His vocals on that song, somehow Bono has this way of evoking emotion that no one will be able to describe it.

Fall Out Boy's Pete Wentz
[Producer and engineer] Jack Joseph Puig was mixing a U2 thing off Joshua Tree and I went in there and he soloed Bono's vocal, and I was like, okay, cool. And then he soloed the Edge's vocal, and I was like, okay, cool. But it was weird, because neither one sounded like U2 to me. Then he played them together, and it actually made a definitive sound. Every band wants to be U2 now, and I always wonder whether it's sonically or career-wise. I think of it in terms of the unrelenting humanitarian stuff Bono does. He gets goofed on for that, but it's pretty amazing in reality if you actually stop and think about it. I went from Guns n' Roses right into Nirvana, and when I was into U2 was Achtung Baby. That was the record I liked, but my friend's older brother would be like, the cool record is Rattle and Hum, or Joshua Tree, but I'm not that cool a guy.

Rob Thomas
The greatest band ever. Here's why I love U2: The only band that I've ever seen, so far, that cares about the music that they make — they don't make a record unless they care about every song that they make — but also care about being the biggest band in the world, unapologetically. Somehow it doesn't fuck up their art. They completely say that they are going to be the biggest band in the world but the music they make is heartfelt, it's sincere. And they go into the studio and fucking beat themselves up over every note, on every record, on every song, and so they bring it to the world. And they don't bring it flippantly. It's hard to say one favorite song. That Atomic Bomb record I lived with for so long, it really ate me up for a while. That and All That You Can't Leave Behind. When my mom died "Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own" really hit me.

Duffy
Bono, what a genius. Joshua Tree — I remember my stepbrother bought it, I think he had to go to like the next town. So it took him a half -hour to drive there. And when he brought it back we all listened to it and it was amazing. Very kind of symbolic moment in my life, we didn't even own any records, there wasn't even a record store in our town. It was sort of the turning of the era. It might have even been on cassette, but it sounded amazing!

Limp Bizkit's Fred Durst
The Edge is an incredible guitar player. He has an incredible style of delays and chords and strumming. Anyone that sounds like Edge, you think he's biting Edge. I'm a fan because of how simple yet complex their music is and how timely the music is. It falls in the pocket and Bono has made himself such a significant part of our culture and even our evolution as our culture. U2 has such a deep meaning behind it. I'm a fan of little bits of all their work, even if one album was better than another. I'm an unconditional fan of U2. I really love the addictive basslines they have. Bono always finds that perfect melody to put in the pocket. I love that song "Beautiful Day." I mean, I love it so much.

Carrie Underwood
"Beautiful Day" is a song that I have always loved. It's one of those songs that never gets old. It's like, when a song is on the radio 5 million times, you might love it in the beginning but the next year you're like, "I hate that song. I wish it would go away." That's one that makes me happy no matter what. We always play it before my shows and everybody hypes up. It makes you feel something really special and brings you to this pretty awesome place.

Darlene Love
I don't really have a favorite U2 song. All I wanna do is work with U2. One of these days. They did a Christmas song, "Christmas Baby (Please Come Home)." They cut it for the Special Olympics and asked me to come in and do the background vocals on it. I did. I thought I was going to meet them, that they were going to be there. They weren't. I've always had this desire. I've run into them, crossed their paths — but I was always either too late or too early. One day before I depart from this Earth, I want to work with them.

Disturbed's David Drainman
The Joshua Tree — "Where the Streets Have No Name" — there's so many great songs on that record and it's such a beautiful collaboration of artistry. It was the one that really put them on the global map. I was a fan of War and the earlier records, but that album really spoke to a greater range of people and transcended them. That's still my favorite. It's a timeless album.
 
Pretty nice to hear stuff from Coyne, but what I got most out of the article was this:

23218194-26544830-lthumbnail.jpg
 
Interesting that people on Interference want the public to love U2 but when somebody comes out and compliments the band people feel embarrassed to be a U2 fan.

No win situation :)

I am glad to hear people respecting U2 these days.
 
Interesting that people on Interference want the public to love U2 but when somebody comes out and compliments the band people feel embarrassed to be a U2 fan.

No win situation :)

I am glad to hear people respecting U2 these days.
I second this comment!
 
This article makes me embarrassed to be a U2 fan.

Um, yes, because it's embarrassing to read other fans' comments because they happen to be famous.

I think it's a great article that shows how many musicians from different musical backgrounds like and respect U2. :up:

Also great to see some love for their newer stuff and not only JT.
 
Sorry, but I'm embarrassed to say I like some of the same music as Fred Durst, Rob Thomas, Fall Out Boy, Disturbed, Carrie Underwood, etc.

If I had never heard of U2 and read this list of musicians they inspired I would assume they were awful. I would almost take this article as if Rolling Stone set out to insult the band.
 
What I like is that some of the new material really is connecting with people. There's somethiing about death and loss in the last two records that people going through the same thing will have a fondness about those records at different points in their life.
 
Sorry, but I'm embarrassed to say I like some of the same music as Fred Durst, Rob Thomas, Fall Out Boy, Disturbed, Carrie Underwood, etc.

If I had never heard of U2 and read this list of musicians they inspired I would assume they were awful. I would almost take this article as if Rolling Stone set out to insult the band.


I find this post embarassing...
 
Um, yes, because it's embarrassing to read other fans' comments because they happen to be famous.

I think it's a great article that shows how many musicians from different musical backgrounds like and respect U2. :up:

Also great to see some love for their newer stuff and not only JT.

:up: :applaud:

This forum has seen several "are U2 relevant" threads. What defines relevance? Album sales (even in this declining market)? Tour success? Or influence on others?

One could argue that U2 have enjoyed the first two for quite a while. Even "Pop" sold 1.5M copies in the U.S. and 6-8M worldwide (depending on which source you read). Most artists wish that their weakest selling album in the last 20 years had those types of numbers.

But to me, relevance is also influence. And reading Pete Wentz's comment about how "everyone wants to be U2" is key. I've been stating this for a while. Coldplay, Fallout Boy, Kings of Leon, The Killers, Franz Ferdinand - even Radiohead - were all influenced by U2. Some have emulated U2's sound to the point that I swear that U2 could have done that song!

Wentz is right in that no one really knows if people are emulating U2 for their style or their success and endurance. But does it matter? Perhaps that style is why U2 has endured for so long.

I was proud reading those comments, from famous names like Darlene Love - a person who has recorded for decades - to more recent artists like Carrie Underwood. This type of influence and impact is huge.

In other words, this article essentially proves U2 is relevant.

And with almost 500K in sales for the first week of NLOTH (in March!), we have further proof. How many other artist who've been around as long as U2 could generate those numbers?
 
I like hearing other musicians praise U2. Thanks for posting!

On the other hand, I have not heard that many musicians truly "diss" U2...other than George Harrison (which was very naiive of him). Are there any musicians who have clearly come out and criticized U2? I dont know how any musician in their right mind could not appreciate what U2 has done for music even if their sound is not their style...
 
taylor swift
i'm a huge u2 fan. "sometimes you can't make it on your own" is my favorite. I actually hadn't heard it and really paid attention to it until i saw it in their 3d movie and i almost started crying because it moved me so much. His vocals on that song, somehow bono has this way of evoking emotion that no one will be able to describe it.

GTFO Taylor Swift
 
This article makes me embarrassed to be a U2 fan.

Same here. Mostly artists who make crap, commercially-accessible music -- except for maybe Coyne and Duffy -- expressing their love for "Beautiful Day", which was an attempt to appeal to these types of people. Watch out for Bono to name-drop them in the next year.
 

Considering her album came out in November and was still at Number 1 until this week (giving it the most weeks at Number 1 for an album this decade), I'd say it was less "GTFO!!!1!" and more like got sick of fucking dominating the album sales charts for the last 4 months and decided to be gracious and let someone else take it for a little while.

NLOTH won't sell half the copies Fearless has. These things will change. Can you feel it now?
 
I always enjoy these articles because the people that I know who hate U2 invariably love some of the bands that worship U2.
 
AH-MAZING ARTICLE!! such a wide range of artist who love my #1 band! I have been so proud to be a fan of U2 for over 20 years :heart:

I esp Love what Rob Thomas said:

Rob Thomas
The greatest band ever. Here's why I love U2: The only band that I've ever seen, so far, that cares about the music that they make — they don't make a record unless they care about every song that they make — but also care about being the biggest band in the world, unapologetically. Somehow it doesn't fuck up their art. They completely say that they are going to be the biggest band in the world but the music they make is heartfelt, it's sincere. And they go into the studio and fucking beat themselves up over every note, on every record, on every song, and so they bring it to the world. And they don't bring it flippantly. It's hard to say one favorite song. That Atomic Bomb record I lived with for so long, it really ate me up for a while. That and All That You Can't Leave Behind. When my mom died "Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own" really hit me.
 
It saddens me that these people believe their last two records were any good. Where is their respect for Zooropa and Pop, albums which actually moved the band forward. No wonder HTDAAB won all those Grammys if that's what "the musical establishment" think.
 
:up: :applaud:
But to me, relevance is also influence. And reading Pete Wentz's comment about how "everyone wants to be U2" is key. I've been stating this for a while. Coldplay, Fallout Boy, Kings of Leon, The Killers, Franz Ferdinand - even Radiohead - were all influenced by U2. Some have emulated U2's sound to the point that I swear that U2 could have done that song!

This is precisely the reason why people are complaining about this article. Artists like the ones you just mentioned are the ones who should be interviewed for something like this, not Carrie Underwood, Taylor Swift, and Fred Durst.

It should have been people from Radiohead, Coldplay, Arcade Fire, Kings Of Leon, Red Hot Chili Peppers, REM, Depeche Mode, etc. I don't have a problem with famous people loving Beautiful Day, but I have a hard time believing that some of these people have ever even heard anything outside of the big singles, that Carrie Underwood has ever even heard Achtung Baby or Zooropa or Pop or The Unforgettable Fire as a whole.

It's ok though, at least the newest RS article about U2 is good :)
 
Same here. Mostly artists who make crap, commercially-accessible music -- except for maybe Coyne and Duffy -- expressing their love for "Beautiful Day", which was an attempt to appeal to these types of people.

I love how you know the secretive motive behind everyone's thinking...:|

Watch out for Bono to name-drop them in the next year.

It doesn't really matter if he does, you'll just make up lies that he did...
 
Back
Top Bottom