In comparison, NLOTH - even if it is the best of the decade, and the best U2 record in a long while - doesn't have *that massive song, and the tour, though innovative, again, isn't as liked as Elevation was. So maybe if the singles don't work any more..it's time to get back to making albums rather than collection of songs.
I felt your post was very well presented and I agree with almost all of your statements, except the above.
While I concur that NLOTH is the best U2 I've heard since AB and, to my ears, is very TUF in nature, I disagree that the tour isn't as "well liked".
So I have to ask - how have you come to this conclusion?
I enjoyed the Elevation tour quite a bit. However, I have loved every show I've attended on this tour - in fact, I have enjoyed them more than any tour since ZOO TV. Given the massive success of this tour, it appears that fans around the world have enjoyed this tour enormously.
Also, while NLOTH has a few exceptions, it is the most "album" like record U2 have made in a long time - possibly since AB. All albums have that token odd song or two that doesn't quite blend in. Sometimes that is intentional. But when a so-so fan of U2 that I know listened to NLOTH for the first time, he actually really liked GOYB feeling it was a great rock track that helped mix up the overall sound.
My point is that we can't judge too much by what the fanatics here write. Die-hards are not the views of the overall fan.
I remember a quote, I think it's from Paul MG, kinda ' a new album out sooner than anyone thinks'. I've never waited so long for an album to be released. He makes a fool of himself.
Given that the time between:
- TUF and JT was 3 years;
- JT and AB was 4.5 years (if you count R&H, then 3 years);
- Zooropa and Pop was about 4 years;
- Pop and ATYCLB was 3.5 years;
- ATYCLB and HTDAAB was 4 years;
- HTDAAB and NLOTH was 4.5 years,
if U2 release an album this year, it would be record-breakingly fast.
For U2.
From that perspective, McGuinness is completely right. After all, it would only be 2+ years. And in truth, that's a normal pace for many artists these days. Add in the worldwide tour and Bono's surgery, 2+ years is actually quite an accomplishment!