I hope they do keep Propaganda status, but only if you continue to subscribe in the off-touring years. And then they can do it like on the 3rd leg - give the Prop members a 1 day advance. Realistically speaking, there are very few Prop subscribers in every city. Not all of them have joined U2.com. And many more will not continue to pay for a subscription when the band is not touring. So we are talking about a tiny, tiny number of people in any given city at any given time who are assured to get tickets. Everyone else can then have an equal shot after.
There is no way they should do it by the membership number. For one, tons of us who were Prop members were waiting for upwards of a month to even get our codes, thanks to their screw up. Why should we now be penalized for that? Second, tons of people had problems with Fanfire not charging their credit cards, double charging, charging 2 weeks later and so on. Why should they be penalized for Fanfire's incompetence.
Bottom line is, if they give Prop subscribers who KEEP subscribing to U2.com every year priority, this won't affect the rest of you. We'll be talking about a tiny proportion of tickets being sold to these people, probably the same amount that would have been allotted to ETS.