American Idol 6

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
Status
Not open for further replies.
u2bonorox said:
I'm very anti-AI, but I'll watch if I can read Golightly's recaps! Sounds like that was a bit of fun! :laugh:
Aw, so sweet. I hope I can do them justice. I'm going to be busy in the next few weeks, so my recaps might be lacking a bit for a while. We'll see what tonight's auditions give me to work with.
 
Oh lord...that rendition of "Under Pressure" :crack:

Ironically I had played that song for my roomie earlier today explaining how Vanilla Ice stole the bass line...and to hear it screeched like that...:crack::banghead:
 
Oh man. This is going to be a loooonnnng round of audition shows. Did we really need to see that first poor girl crying for so long after her audition?

I loved hearing people announce they were from Wisconsin. I actually squealed "EAU CLAIRE!!!" when the "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" girl said she was from there.

<--- former Wisconsin gal
 
A long round indeed :crack:

I agree, they didn't have to focus on the first girl and her misery for so long - uncalled for.

Why...... why... why..... (Under Pressure)
"Kiss" - Every rendition was horrible :yikes:
And the 'Yellow Brick Road' girl. She did her little impression, but then included it in her songs :coocoo:

One night of auditions down, a million to go :corn:
 
They did spend way to much time focusing on that first girl. I also felt bad for the guy at the end who went to learn an Abba song. That must have been tough! I wished he would've brought out more than just the raspy rock voice. I bet he had it in him. I liked that Denise Jackson girl at the beginning. She really had some potential.

Now, that Wizard of Oz girl truly scared me. I hid behind my knees for a second of that. First off, her singing was horrible, and to top that off the impression of the Cowardly Lion was terrible too!! :crack:

So, tomorrow looks like doomsday..................





















.....and I can't wait!! :hyper: :crazy:
 
Yes, everyone gets to see Seattle rain and Seattle crazies! :wink:

<---- no longer in Wisconsin, now in Seattle!
 
How could I forget the AI thread?! Shame on me!

Since I have a new little boy now it's hard to watch all of it like I did last year while I was pregnant just kicking back in the lounge chair. So here's what I have to say about tonight's show...

That was WACK!

You'd figure after 5 years of this, people would learn. But I guess there are still friends and family members that don't have the balls to tell the truth to their so-called singers.

After seeing the commercials, I can't wait for tomorrow night! :hyper:

Bad is good!!! :lol:
 
AI Recaps-January 16th
Minneapolis Auditions

I told myself I wouldn’t get emotionally invested in this season of American Idol. After being put through the wringer last year, and putting my life on hold, I approached season 6 with dread and a wee bit of disgust, mostly at myself. But also because of Simon Cowell’s bitch tits. Those are seriously disturbing.

The season opener shows Taylor Hicks winning season five of American Idol. And then you that’s the last you see of our favorite gray-haired soulster (or spaz, YMMV). I guess “fizzlegate” has bit him on the ass. However, you do see plenty of DAUGHTRY! and Katharine McPhee. Anyway, onto the show.

Auditions start in Minneapolis, home of Prince and Mary Tyler Moore...and countless (deluded) auditioners. Things don’t start off well in the land of many lakes. First, Jewel is a guest judge. Is she still relevant? Does she have an album to promote? Silly me. Of course, she has an album to promote.

Onto the auditions...

At the beginning, we are treated to a girl wearing a cowboy hat simulating an orgasm...or a cat with his tail stuck in the car door. Take your pick.

Jessica: She’s the biggest Jewel fan evah! and a total up-talker. She sings a Jewel song and Jewel looks seriously pissed. Jessica can’t sing and gets a “no” from all of the judges. Thus, she has a nervous breakdown in front of Randy, Jewel, Paula, and Simon. I shed less tears when I got mugged. Still, I liked Jessica. Maybe she can get a gig as a huge celebrity make-up artist and be the next Laura Mercier.

Troy: Urban Amish and he’s from Wisconsin. I should have known. He has no plan and no TV to watch “American Idol.” And he basically has no clue on how to sing.

Next we get a montage of bad singing featuring some interchangeable blondes and some guy who truly sucks. “Jesus Take the Wheel (and Drive Me Away From this Trainwreck).”

Jesse: Mangles the English language. I think I hate him. Then he sings. Now I know I hate him. Leaves, and unfortunately comes back to sing another song. Simon calls Jesse a two-year-old who can’t sing.” Two-year-olds everywhere say, “Bitch, please!”

Charles aka Apollo Creed: He sings REO in Italian. Well, that’s a sentence I never thought I’d write. He doesn’t sing too badly (given some of the competition), but next time leave the crazy at home and bring a better song.

Denise: Brings a sorrowful back story. Was born a crack baby. She’s from Wisconsin. Do not embarrass me! Yes, she can sing. Finally, we get someone who can actually sing. Squee! A fellow cheesehead is going to Hollywood!

Next we have PSA for the AI Appeal-Forgetting Your Words. Sally Struthers behooves you to give.

Tashawn: That was “Kiss?” Are we sure? Prince begins to dig his (very tiny) grave.

Perla: Originally from Columbia and trying to live the American Dream. She asks Ryan if he likes Spanish girls. Yes, he likes Spanish girls who introduce him to their Spanish brothers. What is Perla wearing? Doesn’t she realize that “Grease-You’re the One That I Want” is on another network? However, she can sing and I really like her energy. I can hear her singing Latin-tinged pop.

Matthew the Cowboy: He claims he has a lot of pizzazz. He has as much pizzazz as a dead battery. He sings “Folsom Prison Blues.” Simon shoots Matthew just to see him die.

Jarrod the “Top Gun” guy: He gets his start with “Reagan Idol” and then brings it to “American Idol.” Wow, he can actually sing; he has a good country voice. I just can’t snark on the actually talented ones.

Trista the Cowardly Lion: Wow, you really need courage to listen to her...or ear plugs.

Stephen: He claims he’s a vocal teacher... of singing? He comes across as the Adam Sandler doing “Opera Man.” Randy gives him the Simon treatment. Stephen is encouraged to do off-Broadway...way off-Broadway.

Michelle: Blonde and sings country. Haven’t we been down this road before? However, she can sing and she seems very likable and confident.

Dayna: Has a very nice boss who flew her out to Minneapolis to audition. My boss didn’t bother to learn my name the first couple of months he knew me. I hope Dayna’s boss gets frequent flier mileage. Dayna has power, but is tone deaf. She sings around the office but doesn’t get fired. I’ve known people to get fired for much less.

Matt: I get a total theater geek vibe from him. I’m surprised he didn’t whip out the jazz hands while singing “California Dreamin’” Wow, I actually got verklempt when he called his mom to give her the good news that he’s going to Hollywood. Damn, kid. Don’t make a wuss out of this cynic.

Rachel: She works in her family’s body shop and has joined the Army reserves. Her hubby is in Iraq. I really like her tone. She has a very warm, husky quality that appeals to me. I’m so glad she got through. I really like her.

Sarah: Another Wisconsin girl and she can sing! Tonight is my night! She sings “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” and sounds miles better than Screech McPhee.

Jason: He’s a triple threat. He can dance, juggle, and sing. Okay, he can juggle a little bit. American Idol doesn’t want him but the nearest Renaissance fair might. He gets rejected by the judges and swears more in one segment than I do all month. I laughed at him. Was that mean? Parents stop deluding your kids. At best, your kids will be woefully mediocre.

Brenna: She looks like a cross between a goth and a soccer mom. Her favorite contestant from last year was the very pretty Ace. I heard many stories of Ace being very generous and giving to the fans. However, Ace sweetie, you do not have to be nice to everyone. Brenna, er, sings. MARY, MOTHER OF GOD! MAKE IT STOP!!! Of course, she is shocked that the judges aren’t bowled over and impressed by her ten years of training talent and star quality. She should consider herself lucky that she got to be on her favorite show. Hey, no one has asked me to be on my favorite show “The Office.” I sulk in a corner.

Now we get a montage of bad auditions featuring Prince songs. How is that digging going Oh Purple One?

Josh: Forgoes hockey to audition for “American Idol.” He was inspired by the DAUGHTRY! to show his rocker boy street cred. Ahem. Strike One: Josh sings a Fuel song. Strike Two: He can’t sing. Strike Three: His dad is way cuter. Josh, stick with your band.

Out of all of the people who auditioned in Minneapolis and only 17 made it through. Tomorrow the judges head to Seattle, reportedly the city of suck.

So, how did I do?
 
Can't say I didn't enjoy the show last night and some of those ridiculous renditions esp. of Prince's Kiss and the Oz lion :lmao: but I still think the judges are extremely rude! Do they have to start laughing in their faces like that before they're even done???
 
Man that was one good show last night:crack:

The girl who loved Ace really freaked me out and the girl who was obsessed with the wizard of oz, i'd let her sing another song for me:lmao:

^the judges weren't that bad:shrug: and I thought they should of been more rude for more the funniness of it:lol:
 
the "biggest Idol fan ever" was scary. he flipped up blonde hair and raccoon eyes were bad enough, but then she sings and is like, I've had 10 years of training. Yeah sure you have. :coocoo: I didn't catch the episode at the beginning though, and apparently I missed someone singing a Jewel song. damn, that would have been fun to see! :lol:
 
kellyahern said:


:applaud:

But what is "fizzlegate"? Is it just that he sort of fizzled out or was it an actual incident?

I'm so out of the AI loop :reject:.
In an article in the music magazine called Relix, Taylor mentioned that AI was basically fizzling out for him and he wouldn't watch next season. He came across as very dismissive and ungrateful, like he was above AI (even though it gave him a huge platform to get noticed), and that he was a true musician, blah, blah, pretentious cakes. He later backpedaled on one of the morning news shows that he was actually trying to make way for the next season's winner. Sadly, it didn't come across that way in the article, and Taylor's explanation was pure spin control.
 
Charles aka Apollo Creed: He sings REO in Italian.

That's what I thought he said, too. But then he started singing, and I said, "Oh! He sings ARIA in Italian!" Yeah, opera always gets you far on Idol.

And "Screech McPhee"? Golightly Girl, you are so on my list. :mad:


:wink:
 
corianderstem said:


That's what I thought he said, too. But then he started singing, and I said, "Oh! He sings ARIA in Italian!" Yeah, opera always gets you far on Idol.

And "Screech McPhee"? Golightly Girl, you are so on my list. :mad:


:wink:
Oops, I think you're right. He did sing an aria in Italian. My bad.

And I guess we're going to have to disagree on Kat. I like her when she's more subtle, but when she goes for the Mariah Carey like melisma, she totally loses me.
 
Golightly Grrl said:
And I guess we're going to have to disagree on Kat. I like her when she's more subtle, but when she goes for the Mariah Carey like melisma, she totally loses me.

Gosh ... upon further reflection, I have to admit you're right! :ohmy:

I'll probably end up buying her album when it comes out. She had such shiny hair.

:reject:
 
I thought the Shakira chick sang Shakira perfectly :lol:
Though I dont know if I would have let her through. :huh:
Were they just letting anyone through I mean jeez :crack:
 
Considering they only let through 17 out of however many thousand, they were probably desperate for people to let through.
 
corianderstem said:
Considering they only let through 17 out of however many thousand, they were probably desperate for people to let through.

That was it??? :huh:
Well hopefully they will have better luck in other cities.
 
Sicy said:
I thought the Shakira chick sang Shakira perfectly :lol:
Though I dont know if I would have let her through. :huh:
Were they just letting anyone through I mean jeez :crack:

You could see they liked her from the start even before she sang. I could tell exactly what they were thinking though. The truth is it isn't all about the best voice. It's a big part of it, and she didn't have the worst voice. But she had a look they liked and with a decent voice in this competition, that can go somewhere.

I don't like Shakira's voice so I wasn't amused. :grumpy:

edit: My sister tried out. She graduated college with a vocal performance degree and really wanted to try. To get to what you see on tv, you have a prelim audition. They take like 10 people and you sing all together. The "judges", not the 3 big judges, just some peeps for the show, then pick who they liked, and say, "you 4 go ahead on, the rest of you, thank you, but you do not move on." That's where my sister got cut.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom