I've had SOI on high repeat ever since it's release. I think it's their strongest album since... 2000 at least.
That being said, something has always bothered me about, but I couldn't put my finger on it.
Finally, it hit me!
There are no iconic Edge hooks.
Think about it-- all the greatest U2 songs not only have strong melodies (of which SOI is refreshingly good!), but also a clutch of musical hooks that draw you in.
Just think about Achtung Baby:
Zoo Station, EBTTRT, One, UTEOFW, The Fly, MW, UV... all of them have some front and center guitar line that is quite catchy.
Now quick, name one from SOI!
The musical hook king of SOI, by far, is Adam. All the riffs--namely, Volcano and TIWYCRMN.
Nothing from the Edge sticks out (a couple of solos aside).
Your thoughts?