Take 2 PITNOL and call us next year.
Thanks for being something that is so "not you": sophisticated.
If this is the best you've got, you might want to get that dictionary back out. Grab a thesaurus, while you're at it.
Why should i waste my best with one of the worst, canuck?
Both of you need to let this childish feud go.
Oh, I totally agree, except in the most recent 2 episodes its been him waltzing into threads I've authored for no other reason than to outright troll me.
Oh, I totally agree, except in the most recent 2 episodes its been him waltzing into threads I've authored for no other reason than to outright troll me.
And at that point you have no choice but to engage? Couldn't possibly ignore him?
Mama, he started it.
Couldn't he possibly ignore my threads? Or is posting U2 related material that provocative, just begging for his trolling? Works both ways.
Mama, he's looking at me.
(Just look the other way, sweetie.)
Couldn't he possibly ignore my threads? Or is posting U2 related material that provocative, just begging for his trolling? Works both ways.
Being semi-gospel (think, in the way Still Havent Found is U2-gospel), MOS is probably more suited for her voice than One is, and she hit One out of the park. Only a few U2 fans here think otherwise. On a larger scale in the broader U2 fan world and outside music lovers, people dug it.
There's no way One MJB is U2's worst recording. It just absolutely is not. To say that completely discredits the simple fact that it is in fact still U2 performing the song, very well especially musically.
This is less loathsome than I remeber One being with MJB. I can't wait to hear how MOS sounds. Also, it's good that Bono remembers that MOS exists.
Whoa! I think a LOT of fans here don't like her version of "One" - and I'm one of them. Time has mellowed me a bit on this performance, but when I first heard it, I thought it was horrid.
MJB belted out the song that's not meant to be belted.
Sometimes the song requires a more mellow, pained voice, which Bono beautifully captured in the original.
Who says the song requires that? We do? It's not our song!
Gabriel's defensiveness is very funny considering how adamant he is Jack White's Love is Blindness cover sucks.
You're making it sound as if those who dislike MJB's version have no legitimate reason to do so.
I don't know. Not to argue about MJB's One specifically, but don't you think that a piece of work has a character that it tries to express?.
Any songwriter knows that once a piece is out there, he can't control what happens to it in the imaginations of others
I'm adamant that I don't care for it, that I think it's crappy.
What you don't hear me saying is that the way he plays it isn't how it's "supposed to be played" or that its "murdering" or "raping" the song or any of the other ridiculous adjectives people heap on MJB.
If you can't understand the difference..
I remember you being one of the people who was lambasting it for not including the outro and the way it was played/sung. I could very well be wrong though.
Maybe I did, but I don't recall. I'm sure someone with too much time on their hands will do a search and compile a multi quote to build a massive case about it, though.