Your opinion....

[tackleberry]

A while ago, I made this "history mixes" of U2. A trilogy if you will. One was early years up until Under a Blood Red Sky. 2nd one was Unforgettable fire up until Rattle and Hum. And the 3rd one was Achtung Baby through POP.

Well, now I'd like to make another for their most recent "history" after POP. Here's what I have so far:

1. Beautiful Day
2. Vertigo
3. Walk On
4. Sweetest Thing
5. All Because of You
6. Beat on the Brat
7. Won't get Fooled Again (Irving Plaza)
8. New York
9. Hands that Built America
10. City of Blinding Lights/AWAAW/Miracle Drug
11. Electrical Storm
12. Kite
13. Sometimes you can't make it...
14. Elevation (Tomb Raider)
15. Ground Beneath her Feet
16. Original of the Species
17. Stuck in a Moment (acoustic)

My question is #10. Which of those songs from HTDAAB should it be?

Anything else I'm missing?

Thanks for your help

 

[tennispunk]

dude
leave off "beat on the brat." i think it's the worst thing U2 has ever recorded.

i love bono. a lot. but he should not be covering the ramones.

*waits for attack*

 

[Aardvark747]

agree with tennispunk actually!

 

[jet_jaguar72]

no one should touch the ramones...
respect the legacy...

 

[martha]

COBL is the best of the three for #10.

 

[Scott900]

Miracle Drug - can't stop playing it - probably the emotional highlight of the album. But I think Yahweh might sneak in there too!

 

[boystupidboy]

yep i'm a massive fan of yahweh so its got to be included
"your love is like a drop in the ocean"

 

[snutes1]

Keep AMAAW baby. It rocks

 

[ponkine]

City Of Blidning Lights, the best one from HTDAAB

 

[Axver]

I'd get rid of the covers.

COBL is the best song U2 have recorded since Streets. It HAS to be on there.

Also, shouldn't Sweetest Thing belong on a different collection as it comes from the JT era and was re-recorded before the ATYCLB era began?