When in doubt, use The Hive system for determining votes.
Hive Option 1: The simplest thing to do is look at how popular each song is (including a review of respective chart positions) and vote for that which is the most well-liked outside of Interference. In this case, I think your choice is clear: Elevation must go.
Hive Option 2: Vote for the song you're most "sick" of hearing, irrespective of its musical qualities. In this case, it appears to be IALW.
Hive Option 3: Vote for the song most hated by other Hive members. This is a tough one. While Elevation currently has the most votes, many Hive members seem to approve of the live version. Yet little positive is said about Stuck in a Moment, so that appears to be the answer here.
Hmmmm. Guess Hive methodology just leaves you where you started.
In this case, I'd put ATYCLB on shuffle and vote for whichever song comes up first.