BigMacPhisto
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2002
- Messages
- 6,351
It DOES fit thematically.
Well, I was saying that the band could have felt it didn't fit. Lyrically and sonically, it certainly does.
It DOES fit thematically.
Well, I was saying that the band could have felt it didn't fit. Lyrically and sonically, it certainly does.
This. Fuck Streets, I sincerely hope they have moved past 25 song mass appeal shows, and even stadiums.
i heard the next tour is going to be mostly bars and a few house parties
Ordinary Love is probably a bit less likely. Too tied to the film/Mandela and it's not exactly the most exciting thing they've done. Again, another lock for that hypothetical third Best Of.
With any luck, we've heard the last of Ordinary Love. It's clearly the worst song in U2's "new era" and there's not a single song on the new album that's not miles better than Ordinary Love. What song from the new record, or from their back catalogue, should they cut to make room for this clunker? Given the relative lyrical comeback for Bono on this record, I'm not sure why he'd want to return to this embarassment.
I just don't see a place of for it in the set list. Thematically, it has even less to do with the themes on the new record than it had to do with Nelson Mandela (which was nothing). Talk about something that will go off like a lead balloon in concert. Though who knows, maybe they'll turn it into the obligatory Bono/Edge acoustic break (i.e. the audience bathroom break). And no doubt we'll hear it again whenever Winnie Mandela is in the news.
I do hope and think they'll play Invisible. Possibly as the closer.
You mean "Presented by Apple"? I'd give it a 50% chance.
...I don't see The Troubles getting a run, except for a one-off if Lykke Li does a guest appearance...
When U2 played the Joshua Tree tour, they opened with Where the Streets Have No Name. It welcomed us into the new sound.
ZOOTV opened with Zoo Station and then a flurry of Achtung songs. It enveloped us in the new sound.
POP began with Mofo. From the start it felt very different from past tours. We were inthe thick of the new sound.
etc.
I think the first track matters. I don't just want to see "A" U2 show. I want to experience the new U2, the U2 which only exists at this moment in time, and will be gone soon. I don't want to feel that U2 is great and they happen to have some new songs. I want to experience the new album, and then half-way through have them remember the identities they used to have at different periods in their career.
I want an Innocence show, not a U2 show.
Obviously, I didn't suggest they only play 2 Soi songs.
When U2 played the Joshua Tree tour, they opened with Where the Streets Have No Name. It welcomed us into the new sound.
ZOOTV opened with Zoo Station and then a flurry of Achtung songs. It enveloped us in the new sound.
POP began with Mofo. From the start it felt very different from past tours. We were inthe thick of the new sound.
etc.
I think the first track matters. I don't just want to see "A" U2 show. I want to experience the new U2, the U2 which only exists at this moment in time, and will be gone soon. I don't want to feel that U2 is great and they happen to have some new songs. I want to experience the new album, and then half-way through have them remember the identities they used to have at different periods in their career.
I want an Innocence show, not a U2 show.
All the shows opened by Stand By Me/C'mon Everybody rang. They say hi.
I see your point about the first song having a role in setting the tone, and I definitely appreciate that you want a specific experience of a particular U2 era. However, I think opening the show with a new song is just a way of doing that, not the only way. Imagine a set with every song from SOI sprinkled throughout it - a couple of rockers at the start, something slower in the middle for atmosphere, an acoustic b-stage track, a big single at the end, The Troubles to close, etc. How does that become any less of an SOI experience because, say, Beautiful Day or Pride opens the show rather than a new song? Especially if that old song is part of a seamless, effective opening sequence that includes new songs?
As I have already said, fixation on a specific setlist slot being filled by songs from a specific album is an overly narrow perspective and misses the point; you can achieve the same goal multiple ways.
Encore: The band brings live wolves on stage.
Stand By Me was great, as were the other covers, but it was really the warm up. The show really started with WTSHNN.
I don't have anything to add. I think the opening song sets the tone for the show. There's no moment in the night with the excitement of track one. I want that to be a song from the new album. And yes, I hope they play as many new songs as possible as well.
If U2 don't feel the confidence in the new material to open with it, maybe it wasn't time to release the album yet. A new album should be strong enough to open with a track from it.
But you are taking this opening song business as a point of faith, so unless you're willing to be rational about this discussion then I'm uninterested in pursuing this further.