starvinmarvin
Refugee
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2005
- Messages
- 1,178
I think that although HTDAAB is better, more consistently good album than ATYCLB (the second half of which is the aural equivalent of a coma), the best songs on ATYCLB outperform the best songs on ATYCLB.
Beuatiful Day is better than Vertigo.
Kite is better than Sometimes.
Walk On is better than Yahweh
the list goes on....
HTDAAB is more even, but ATYCLB's highest points tower above the new album's best moments. This is part of the reason why the setlists for the Vertigo tour have been less than satisfactory - the new songs don't quite match up to the rest of the classic songs the band plays as much as the best ALTYCLB songs did during Elevation.
What do you think?
Beuatiful Day is better than Vertigo.
Kite is better than Sometimes.
Walk On is better than Yahweh
the list goes on....
HTDAAB is more even, but ATYCLB's highest points tower above the new album's best moments. This is part of the reason why the setlists for the Vertigo tour have been less than satisfactory - the new songs don't quite match up to the rest of the classic songs the band plays as much as the best ALTYCLB songs did during Elevation.
What do you think?