intedomine
Rock n' Roll Doggie FOB
All of the negative ones are garbage. Just the anti-u2 crowd coming out in force. Interesting to note that they are usually written by first time reviewers.
check out 5 stars reviews as well...intedomine said:All of the negative ones are garbage. Just the anti-u2 crowd coming out in force. Interesting to note that they are usually written by first time reviewers.
ponkine said:check out 5 stars reviews as well...
PS: stop saying "1 star reviewers are just anti- U2" and all that. That´s not true at all. People simply dislike this album, no matter you are or aren´t agree with that.
There´s a problem with every new U2 album, I mean, it must be something holy. If anyone says "Boy is just crap", "Pop is horrible", etc, nobody feel as bad as if someone say "HTDAAB is the same crap again". What´s the point with a new album? we can´t dislike it because it´s new?
If you don´t want to see the truth, that´s your problem. People simply don´t like this album, at least they´re very divided.
I know U2 can do so much better than this ATYCLB II cocktail
Yahweh said:a lot of Americans have been taking an anti-U2 stance for a long time its really nothing new.
why? you simply don´t want to see the truth. Come on, give me another of your endless repertorie of insults again and againSleep Over Jack said:Please go away..
Hoodlem said:The more people hate it the better if you ask me. Maybe we will get to have U2 back to ourselves again.
.
ponkine said:why? you simply don´t want to see the truth. Come on, give me another of your endless repertorie of insults again and again
PS: you won´t want to see All That You Can´t Leave Behind fan rating from www.metacritics.com
Marr said:
I agree. You can't sell U2's music to people who like Britney Spears or Eminem. It doesn't work this way. It doesn't matter if they sell 4 million of 14 million albums. POP wasn't a best-seller yet it's a great album. U2's all been more then just MTV and radio and they don't need to be praised by people you know shit about music.
ATYCLB and HTDAAB are too radio friendly,
it's musical populism.
It's pop. I prefer rock.
Yahweh said:I want to know how Vertigo, Sometimes You Cant Make It On Your Own, Miracle Drug and so on sound anything like Eminem or Britney Spears?
Sleep Over Jack said:
Y'know, theres a lot of "pop" in The Smiths sound.
Yahweh said:I want to know how Vertigo, Sometimes You Cant Make It On Your Own, Miracle Drug and so on sound anything like Eminem or Britney Spears?
Marr said:
not that kind of pop, not something like "vertigo"....
I'd say that the Smiths were always indie or alternative call it what you will, but they stand there with bands like The Clash, Jane's Addcition or Faith No More. Their sound is different but their values and principles are anti-pop.
Sleep Over Jack said:
I've never heard any punk rock riffs from The Smiths...they had a lot of melody in their sound, which is a major component of pop, even if their lyrics were not.
Sleep Over Jack said:You said Vertigo was pop, I'm just pointing out its heavier than what The Smiths came up with..
Marr said:
so it's a heavy guitar driven, radio friendly pop song...
Yahweh said:Why is The Fly any different?
Yahweh said:Why is The Fly any different?
Marr said:
You think there is no difference between The Fly and Vertigo?
Let me point out a few:
1.The Fly's lyrics have a meaning
2. It's no radio friendly
3. It sounds a lot more aggressive and rock and roll then any song on the Bomb. They had different attitude then....