phanan
Blue Crack Addict
In Rainbows was way too high. Sorry, I really like the album, but no way it's up there.
The Bends should have easily finished ahead of it.
The Bends should have easily finished ahead of it.
hmm, I think only 6 albums I had in my top 50 made the cut
I would have expected a couple more but it's not too bad
what I don't understand though is how on a list so top heavy with "classic classics" that Rolling Stone woud print it without blinking twice Pet Sounds doesn't end up waaaaaaaaay higher
because some of the albums that are ahead of it now are really just ... umm .... well, it should have been higher
i'm disappointed at the lack of bloc party.
Well this fucking blows. Although my list was sent to LemonMelon, he must not have gotten it. Or maybe I don't count. Cuz my top 50 wasn't posted.
No, I did get it. It should have been on the list above MrPryck2U. It's nothing personal, I just screwed up.
CIB's list wasn't included because of Stop Making Sense, and Anu sent me a list that needed correction, but didn't fix it in time.
I understand. You told me to take out Legend. I wish I knew live albums weren't accepted.
I wish I had seen Stop Making Sense before so I could have mentioned it. It must have changed position or something, because I didn't notice it the first time.
I am surprised there was no love for Beck, Odelay?! Come on guys, two turntables and a mircophone!
I'm more surprised there was no Sea Change, I figured that one would have been a shoe in...
I'm more surprised there was no Sea Change, I figured that one would have been a shoe in...
Sea Change got damn close. One more high placing would have done it.
you think between scumbo and impy this could have happened
I'm actually really interested to see how the rankings would have differed had they entered lists. I feel like a lot of my indie albums would've had a better chance at making the list, since some of them ended up in the 50 honorable mentions.
less stones/bowie/Zeppelin is a good thing imo...
I am surprised there was no love for Beck, Odelay?! Come on guys, two turntables and a mircophone!
If Saracene's a girl, then I think I'm in love!
it felt like I was reading something from Rolling Stone - very safe choices in a lot of cases...
I'm not saying there is anything wrong with that either, it just would have been nice for something more interesting than Arcade Fire to make an appearance or two...