Sorry guys,
but this is not really a competition:
GILMOUR BY FAR
Just his work on songs like Comfortably Numb, Time, Money, Echoes, One Of These Days, Dogs, High Hopes, etc alone put Edge's work onto shame
IMHO The Edge is one of the best guitar players, in the way that he added something different, unique, something that you can't separate from the songs that they sounded great
as Pride, Streets, Bad, Sunday Bloody Sunday, I Will Follow, With Or Without You, etc...
but ...
Edge didn't and won't reach the timeless playing of Gilmour
(Comfortably Numb has been voted several times as the best ever guitar solo, avobe other classic ones as Stairway To Heaven, Purple Haze, Child In Time, etc, etc) Also Gilmour is a better songwriter (without AMLOR, of course) and his singing has been far more important than Edge one