Dirty Day vs Please

[MrBrau1]

 

[xaviMF22]

lame.

 

[phillyfan26]

Studio:
Please - B
Dirty Day - F

Live:
Please - A+
Dirty Day - A

Please wins.

 

[Chizip]

Studio:
Please - B
Dirty Day - F

F? Really? I admit Dirty Day is 10 times better live, but I think the studio version gets too much flack. It has a beautiful elegance about it. Listen to it again on headphones right now and come back and tell me it's an F.

F is reserved for songs like New York

 

[mysterious_jen]

dirty day (live)
mostly because the lyrics mean alot to me and the guitar solo at the end eg- sydney dvd ... wow.

 

[U2girl]

Please.

 

[last unicorn]

Please

Genius.

 

[U2lunatic]

I hate Dirty Day studio version, it's even worse than Elevation on album. But live it kicks ass,..... even though only when Edge plays it with strat, I don't like version from Sydney DVD. Please is very good in studio, and in my opinion it's not very different from concert version so Please is winner.

 

[tpsreports2424]

Both in the studio sucked I thought, and both are really good live so Dirty Day

 

[WCF]

I have to go with Dirty Day

 

[schnumi]

Both Live and Studio: Please.

One of the greatest U2 songs ever made that's for sure.

Although Dirty Day live is very very very good, they should get it back on the setlist for the next tour! together with please.

 

[phanan]

Please, although the single version with the guitar solo is better.