U2 Songs in EW

[U2Girl1978]

So I was glancing through the current issue of Entertainment Weekly and they have a section of the 50 greatest love songs of all time. U2-All I want is you is at #9..

And the ten readers favorites U2-With or Without you is #5..

 

[firstlove]

yay! that is so great, more recognition for our favorite band in the world!

 

[Windmilllane]

are you kidding me?

All I Want is You is not a love song. It's too mellow and depressing. When you think love song, think Barry Manilow or "My Endless Love" by Lionel Ritchie. It has to be sappy.

 

[lmjhitman]

are you kidding me? All I Want is You is not a love song.

I'm not so sure about With or Without You either.

 

[madonna's child]

with or without you is NOT a love song. all I want is you is a little closer, but it's certainly not really romantic.