LMP
Blue Crack Supplier
I forgot about Mass Effect. Both are great. I've never replayed a RPG, but they get more and more intuitive, so, the gaming experience can be totally different the 2nd time around if you take a different moral path, etc.
GTA IV, you need that. Just total adrenaline, and of course the freedom to do missions or just randomly fuck everyone in Liberty City up.
This is true. I tried doing that with Knights of the Old Republic a few years back, and while it was interesting to see the differences, it still didn't match up to the first time I played it. The opposite can be said for a game like Gears or Halo 3.
Yeah, last time I played I went on this French Connection-esque car chase throughout the city... fucking epic. That must be sick on LIVE, too.