McCormick tells a bit more on the album

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

U2girl

Blue Crack Addict
Joined
Sep 28, 2000
Messages
21,113
Location
slovenija
atU2tour.de/hotpres.com

... And it's not called Vertigo! The man otherwise known as "Bono's doppelganger", Neil McCormick, talks sounds, songwriting and stadium-sized pressure in the most revealing U2 album preview yet.

The author of I Was Bono's Doppelganger and the forthcoming U2 interview book, Neil McCormick, has been talking to hotpress.com about the band's eagerly awaited studio album.

"All the song titles and the album title itself that have been circulating are wrong," he reveals. "There?s some powerful disinformation going on there ? probably coming from them! So the album isn?t called Vertigo and none of those song titles that people are probably searching desperately for on the internet are song titles on the album. I don?t know if I?m allowed to divulge the title, if they?re keeping it secret then they?ve got their own reasons to do that. It?s an interesting title, an interesting philosophical idea as a title, and quite a difficult title."

McCormick, a lifelong friend of Bono's, does however confirm that 'Vertigo' is the title of the collection's flagship single.

"The first single ?Vertigo? refers back to their past," he resumes. "Bono sings at one point, "Hello, hello" and I said, ?You?ve used that line before? and he said, ?Have I? Where?? and I said, ?Well you used to use it all the time basically when you ran out of words! And on ?Stories For Boys?.? And that?s on their first single.

"So their new single refers back to their first. It?s like the early U2 pumped up in the 21st century, a really exciting record. It actually includes my name in it, so I definitely voted for that as the first single! At the end Bono?s singing something like, "You gotta learn how to kneel." And then he goes: "Kneee-heel!" And they were playing this in the studio and at that exact moment they all just looked up and saw me standing there and went, 'Hey Neil!'"

As for the overall feel of the record, the former Hot Press staffer proffers that, "The songwriting that you?ve seen on All That You Can?t Leave Behind, it?s that songwriting. U2 records were never so crafted in the past. I think they always had to draw too much on what Bono could do in the moment, and that?s a lot of pressure to put on one person.

"Nowadays they go into the studio with a song and then they kick it around and the lyrics change completely, and I bet you all those false titles are probably the original titles that these songs had. But really a U2 record isn?t finished until Bono sings the lyric and the lyric isn?t finished until he sings it.

"The songwriting refers to practically every stage of U2?s development," McCormick continues, "so it?s quite a backward looking album in that, but it?s got a more unified Edge-driven sound. Y?know, Edge has always been the musical genius in U2 and not given the credit with people talking of Bono all the time. Bono is the psyche and the driving force of U2, but Edge is the musical wizard, and this feels like an Edge record."

Despite Bono publicly saying otherwise, McCormick insists, "it?s not the U2 big rock record; there are maybe three rock songs on there, but there?s all the usual ambience and weird adventures, and all of the songs are about big themes.

"It?d be interesting if U2 could ever make a marginal or personal or intimate record again; in a way they can?t because they?ve raised the stakes to such a level that they have to knock a stadium monster out, they have to knock that ball out of the stadium every time.

"They spent two and a half years making this record. I heard this record, some of it, a year ago, and I thought it was finished. But you cannot criticise their way of working ?cos they do knock it out of the stadium. I don?t think they can make a throwaway record anymore. They have to make a record that speaks to the world because the world is paying attention."

Due to hit the racks next week with I Was Bono's Doppelganger - the title for it's American release (October 1) is the rather more sensational Killing Bono - McCormick is currently conducting the interviews for the 'in their own words' U2 book that's due in 2005.

"I'm only up to 1983 with Bono and 1987 with Edge," he laughs, "so there's quite a bit more work to do! It's going to make for a great read though."

Peter Murphy's full interview with Neil McCormick will be publlished in the next issue of Hot Press, in stores Thursday, August 26.
 
Last edited:
U2girl said:
Despite Bono publicly saying otherwise, McCormick insists, "it?s not the U2 big rock record; there are maybe three rock songs on there, but there?s all the usual ambience and weird adventures, and all of the songs are about big themes.



I knew it.
Vertigo will be the first single and big rock tune, then we'll get ATYCLB. Which is fine as long as the songs are great. I don't need an entire album of vertigo.
 
Last edited:
So maybe the title is How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb or whatever that title was but at the same time he says it's NOT the rumoured titles floating around which includes the Atomic one. :scratch:
 
I don?t know how you would interpret this but I would say we are up for an ALTYCLB2.... Yeea -haaa :silent: :)yuck: ).... The positive thing - which I really cling on to - is the comment about the record beeing Edge?s record....
 
I was hoping for an full rock album
with at most 2 or 3 ballad-like songs on it...
Consider McCormick is part of it
and probably part of the confusion plan... :yes:
 
Last edited:
3 rockers would make it like every other u2 album. people complaining about the same formula that has made this band the greatest in the world. U2 never does a whole album of rock numbers, and they never do a whole album of ballads. there are always some, for lack of a better word, in-between songs. its not going to be three rock songs and 8-9 ballads, they have never done that. i want there to be those great songs that are not ballads but the huge emotional songs, like bad, streets, or please. everything he says in this article is what i would expect from u2. sounds good to me.
 
maybe the title is "Kneel"
(or "dargon")

and

"You gotta learn how to kneel."
haven't we heard that before in "Mysterious Ways"...another AB :hyper:
 
Last edited:
jphelmet said:
3 rockers would make it like every other u2 album. people complaining about the same formula that has made this band the greatest in the world. U2 never does a whole album of rock numbers, and they never do a whole album of ballads. there are always some, for lack of a better word, in-between songs. its not going to be three rock songs and 8-9 ballads, they have never done that. i want there to be those great songs that are not ballads but the huge emotional songs, like bad, streets, or please. everything he says in this article is what i would expect from u2. sounds good to me.

True. 3 big rock songs is about right. AB had The Fly, Acrobat, UTEOTW. ATYCLB had BD, Elevation, NY. JT had Bullet and Exit.
Everyone needs to stop focusing on the term "big rock songs". We're going to get tunes to rival Bad, Kite, One, Please, Streets, etc. The best song on this album won't be one of the rock ones. It'll be one of those emotional/creative ones that sneak up on ya.
 
Don't like the part when he says that it's ATYCLB songwriting. But then he says that the songwriting goes back to every U2 album in the past. Hm. I expected the "3 rock tunes" statement, so it's not a surprise to me. What I love the most about this article is that "it is Edge's record". I love that quote!
 
Whatever it is, it'll be different. U2 never repeat itself and just look at Vertigo. No one expected that sound from the new single. I think this album will very unique and different than what U2 has done in the past.
 
we are all on fire with these previews and rumours. Everybody is alreday expecting everything. If we don't start to to hear it soon some of us will go mad... well, at least me.
 
It?s an interesting title, an interesting philosophical idea as a title, and quite a difficult title."

Wander if that was ever quoted about POP..:wink:

Is 'How to dismantle an atomic bomb' a philosophical idea?
 
I am thinking this album will be Boy meets Achtung Baby.....It will be great in about 1 month when Vertigo hits the radio to stop speculating what this album will sound like. I will be shocked if this album is not their greatest ever. I think U2 is way to smart to spend this much time on this album for it not to be great.
 
Tizer, I agree with your thought. 'How to dismantle an atomic bomb' seems like a big philosophical idea. I would wager a guess, based on what we've read to this point, that that would be the album title

HTDAAB:wink:
 
:hmm: It's not any of the titles circulating around?

I think after an album titled by a song/lyric bit it IS time for an album titled by an idea. Perhaps a religious idea?

ATYCLB songwriting probably just means they will follow the verse/chorus/verse/solo-middle bit/ending formula, I don't think he meant the sound. Or it could mean there will be less Bono-written lyrics and more Bono&Edge-written lyrics.

We know the song bits (at least ABOY for me) and that sounded nothing like ATYCLB, and it doesn't coincide with saying it's an Edge record. To me, Edge based U2 albums are the first three, Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby.
 
As for rocking songs, U2 always has a mix of rockers, mid tempo and ballads. 2-3 is the average. :yes:

(though AB holds the record with Zoo station, Even better than the real thing, Acrobat, Until the end of the world and The fly. Do we count Mysterious ways too? :confused: )
 
ATYCLB songwriting scares me. I think it was among the worst U2 has done. Why? Because it is so un-subtle. Achtung Baby was great because you had to listen carefully to the lyrics and read into them, it was poetic. ATYCLB was just slap-you-in-the-face sort of stuff so that the lowest common denominator would understand - I mean "peace on earth", "grace"??? Give me a break, there was a time when U2 could convey those ideas indirectly and subtly and thus more powerfully. So I hope ATYCLB songwriting refers to the music and NOT the lyrics.
I also liked Neil's point about U2 being unable to release marginal albums anymore. That is what made U2 great - you may not like them but it was albums liked Zooropa, Pop, and even Passengers that kept U2 from becoming the Rolling Stones and I think the success of ATYCLB probably has now turned them into such a band - a band that may endure for years to come but which will not produce important albums. I hope not, and I hope the new album proves me dead wrong - just that comment about the songwriting got me worked up a bit...:|
 
I guess ATYCLB was just a straight forward lyric phase for Bono. I like his lyrics on virtually all albums. I mean, in the end I don't care if it's in your face or subtle, if it means something to you that's what matters.

I thought it was albums like Zooropa, Passengers and Pop that almost destroyed their career and/or turned them into obscurity a la Radiohead or Pearl Jam. ATYCLB was a good step away from that phase - obviously for the fans too, since a lot more of them bought it than U2's last two albums.
 
Last edited:
i have to say even better... is not a rocker. this is totally a subjective thing, but i still think that is one of the worst u2 songs, and is cheesy pop song not a rocker.
 
Hi. First time poster. Despite the fact that this may not be an all out rock and roll record, the McCormick quote talking about "usual ambience and weird adventures" signals to my hopeful self that this in no way will be ATYCLB pt 2. A great album, but lets move on to better things. "Usual ambience and weird adventures"...good good. Thats what I was expecting from punk rock made on Venus.
 
3 REAL rock songs will be better than their last album. New York is mostly slow except the chorus (I really don't care for that song either) & BD is not quite a full-on rock song. Elevation was the only real rock song all the way through.
 
3 rock songs? some people DESPISE Pop (me not included, I love it) and it has 7-8 rock songs, so i dont know why people are mad about having 3 big rock songs. AB only had Zoo Station, Even Better, The Fly, UTEOTW. I have a feeling we're in for Acthing Baby II, and i can't fuckin' wait!!!
 
On initial listen, the worst part for me about ATYCLB wasn't the songwriting necessarily, (although "a mole, digging in a hole" isn't the greatest) but it was more Bono's voice. It sounded extremely strained, especially on songs like Wild Honey and WILATW. As for the songwriting, certainly the album didn't have the depth and intimacy of achtung baby, but then again as larry has said, ATYCLB was U2 competing with Brittany Spears. In the years up to the release, boy bands were all the rage and i think that probably influenced their songwriting (to some extent). They were looking for songs with immediate tunefulness. On that level i think it was a resounding success. This album, they really aren't out to prove anything to anyone, so it should be more natural and U2 like, which is a good thing.
 
GregoCrandor said:
"Usual ambience and weird adventures"...good good. Thats what I was expecting from punk rock made on Venus.


those are the neil words that made me excited as well.
based on the "leaks" of songs we have seen, it is obvious there is some high energy on this album.
i was more worried they'd neglect the adventurous side .....
but taste is so subjective.
even interpreting these quotes is subjective......
bring on vertigo!
 
3 rock songs! I think that is more than what All That... had to offer (and I am a huge fan of All That...). Even the heaviest songs off All That... were strong pop songs at best (except for Kite which was like a 45rpm Who rock song being played at 33rpm). Of course everything is subjective here and you could argue anyway you see it, but what I really loved about Neil's comments (and this was pointed out earlier here) was that this is an Edge album. That comment, to me, speaks volumes and right away separates itself from All That... .

Another month till we hear just one song! AHHHH!!! Time feels soooooooo sllllllllllllllloooooooooooowwwwwwwwwwwww. :(
 
Back
Top Bottom