The Sad Punk
Blue Crack Addict
Is anybody actually happy with their list? I hated mine.
There are 5 songs on Meddle that aren't Echoes. There are 3 songs on WYWH that aren't Shine On You Crazy Diamond. While it doesn't make all that large of a difference time-wise, SOYCD absolutely kills the momentum of the album due to its placement, and the album lacks variety because of it.
A better question for you to ask me would be why I prefer Animals over WYWH, though they're structured similarly. Simply put, I just prefer the songs. Animals slays for its entire duration, while there are a couple of duds on WYWH that I could do without. Pretty simple, but I think those two albums are more comparable.
Innervisions made my list.
Is anybody actually happy with their list? I hated mine.
Oasis did that uptight song better.....
SOYCD...is the perfect opener, one of the best ever, and then to come back to it after the three songs in the middle is pure magic.
Not sure what you mean about how SOYCD kills the momentum. It's the perfect opener, one of the best ever, and then to come back to it after the three songs in the middle is pure magic. If the second part was placed in the middle of the three other songs, then I'd be inclined to agree, but it's not.
no, I don't think so, when Mel and his accounting firm are finished tabulating the results I think he is going to post all the lists in the results thread so we can make fun of you.
no, I don't think so, when Mel and his accounting firm are finished tabulating the results I think he is going to post all the lists in the results thread so we can make fun of you.
that's because we're awesomeI did like Khan did, in that I tried not to fret to much, didn't spend too much time on it, it made it much easier
i like mine. most will probably go if they see my list, but whatevs.Is anybody actually happy with their list? I hated mine.
What's Going On made mine as well, but I hadn't heard Innervisions in a long time, so it wasn't included.
Nico definitely made mine, but White Light / White Heat cracked the Top 25.
I haven't listened to Nico enough, methinks, but I've found some of it difficult to get into.
can i still turn mine in today?
Yeah. The lists are due tomorrow.