Muggsy
Refugee
I can't agree with you more, Golightly Girl
Irvine511 said:
for the people who have chosen not to have children, why? how do people react when they find out you are childless?
Irvine511 said:
though i'd love to shift the conversation away from "parents we can't stand" and try to focus on the pressures to become parents and how we respond to them, and why people have chosen not to have children.
for the people who have chosen not to have children, why? how do people react when they find out you are childless?
Irvine511 said:for the people who have chosen not to have children, why? how do people react when they find out you are childless?
Golightly Grrl said:
But I'm not that much of a monster
MrsSpringsteen said:
But no guy is an incomplete male if he doesn't want kids
That's an awfully sweeping generalization...for one thing, I think it's more often "accepted" than "applauded," and that also it's far more accepted in middle-class WASP culture than in other circles. Certainly in the subcultural niche I grew up in, the prevailing idea was that you aren't a "real man" unless you're a husband and father, period, even though job success was also important (and nowadays, your stereotypical Jewish grandmother is more likely to be overheard advising her granddaughters, "Take your time...go to grad school, do an internship, and if you want to be a homemaker, at least do some volunteer or part-time work in whatever field you studied for, so that you've got a foot in the door for later when the kids are grown"). My black and Latino male friends generally report being raised with similar ideas. Plus, unmarried childless men do get sermons all the time from their married-with-children male friends on all the wonderful things they're missing, I'm-telling-ya-man-it-really-grows-you-up, etc. I also think--and I suspect this is kind of what indra was saying--that a lot of men do choose to marry and have kids out of little more (or really, not enough more) than a vague sense that they haven't really "arrived" as a man until they can claim to have produced and suported a family.MrsSpringsteen said:a guy who has many "conquests" and lives let's just say a happy single life without the commitment of kids and marriage, is applauded.
melon said:
The thing is, non-white populations are generally having plenty of children, so if we're afraid of the extinction of the human race, it's not likely going to happen. But that's what scared racist groups, and that's why they started this kick condemning childless (white) couples; it's because they feel increasingly threatened by brown people.
Melon
Many pregnant women 'unprepared'
BBC, Aug. 31, 2006
One in five pregnant women say they do not feel "emotionally ready" to have a baby, a survey has revealed. The poll of 1,100 women found many women were surprised at the physical and emotional demands of pregnancy. Half felt under pressure to be "perfect", and 44% said those around them felt the need to pass on "tips"...67% felt more exhausted than expected during pregnancy, and 58% felt more emotional. Over half said they felt more in need of reassurance than they expected, but 29% felt confused by all the conflicting advice they read. A third said they had received personal comments that upset them, such as being told about other people's pregnancy and birth "horror stories".
Just over a quarter (27%) said they were weighed down by relationship or financial pressures. And 10% of pregnant women felt pressure from friends who said they had "lost" them socially. The poll also found that 21% felt pressure from media coverage of celebrities who appeared to lose all their pregnancy weight straight away...One woman said: "People find it entirely acceptable to pass comment about my body shape whilst I am pregnant - the size of my hips, the weight I'm carrying, the size and position of my bump. They would never dream of being so direct and rude if I wasn't pregnant."
Experts said more services should be available to support pregnant women and to stop them feeling so isolated. Dr Linda Papadopolous...said: "[These] statistics...show just how little pregnant women are being supported through their pregnancy - and how this is detrimentally affecting them, both mentally and physically...It's evident that the mounting pressure on women to remain perfect throughout pregnancy and motherhood is huge. This problem needs to be addressed - women mustn't be left feeling so isolated."
melon said:You know, society has expended an awful lot of effort trying to discourage teenage pregnancy by highlighting all the disadvantages of having children. Perhaps once these teens become adults, they still remember how "disadvantageous" it is to have children.
Melon
Not entirely racism, in cases where there is common culture the shift in racial demographic is no barrier whatsoever but the issue is that there will be a dramatic cultural shift in western countries if you have Muslim minorities becoming large minorities over the next 50 years to majorities over the next century that do not have any interest to integrate, reading stories where a majority of British Muslims (or Muslims who live in Britain) want to see Sharia be introduced and for blasphemy to be made a crime is worrying, especially when it's not the immigrants rather the second and third generation who embrace stricter religious views as a means of identity.sulawesigirl4 said:melon, I think you bring up an important point. Most of this fear and hand-wringing over low birth rates aren't because the world is in danger of under-population (hardly!) but because whites are reproducing in lower numbers than non-whites. Quite frankly, in a probably childish and perverse way, I look forward to having children with my black boyfriend if only to muddy up the gene pool even more.
Birth VideoDevlin said:
Melon! Two Words: Birth Video.
Not even for Larry Mullen would I have a child. Though I'd be soreley tempted if he were charming enough.
ON choosing not to have children:
I am rather like Adam on that score. Don't like 'em, don't want 'em, keep 'em away from me.
I mean, I have a vague, distant sort of affection for my nieces and nephews and various other children I know personally. But, to be honest, I barely know the names of my nieces and nephews, and I cannot for the life of me remember ages or which is which. Sad, isn't it?
The only kid I even know well is my now..17 (I think!) year old cousin, and I didn't even bother with him much until he was old enough to roughhouse with.
Reason 2538 for me to like Adam.Devlin said:I am rather like Adam on that score. Don't like 'em, don't want 'em, keep 'em away from me.
sulawesigirl4 said:
Another thought I had when reading the original article was that any kind of "punishment" of childless people (economic or otherwise) is destined to just bring more meddling in people's private lives. How do you determine who is willfully childless and who is childless because of medical reasons. Is that the government's job to determine and control? Would a childless couple have to submit to medical testing in order to get out of the tax penalty? The whole idea is just ludicrous and actually really scary, imho.
LivLuvAndBootlegMusic said:
Reminds me of Ceaucescu's Romania *shudder*.....
martha said:
That's what I've been thinking about as well.
And the Romanians shot that fucker at dawn one Christmas day.
BonosSaint said:
If someone is judged by the willingness to take on responsibility for something other than himself/herself, the ability to love unconditionally, the ability to create a personal community both dependent on and responsible for each other, taking care of those least able to take care of themselves, there are many ways of doing this, including raising children.