U2 Video Contest

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

JMScoopy

Refugee
Joined
Mar 23, 2004
Messages
1,268
Location
Near Pittsburgh
I don't know if this has been done before.

Rate the following U2 videos (VHS and DVD)

Under a Blood Red Sky
Rattle & Hum
Zoo Tv Live From Sydney
Popmart Live From New Mexico
Elevation Boston
Elevation Slane
Vertigo Chicago

7 points for #1
6 points for # 2 etc etc
 
1. Rattle and Hum - 7
2. Elevation Slane - 6
3. Vertigo Chicago - 5
4. Elevation Boston - 4
5. Popmart - 3
6. ZooTV - 2
7. UABRS - 1
 
1. Zoo Tv Live From Sydney-7
2. Elevation Slane - 6
3. Popmart Live From New Mexico -5
4. Under a Blood Red Sky -4
5. Elevation Boston -3
6. Rattle & Hum -2
7. Vertigo Chicago -1
 
1. Under A Blood Red Sky
2. Rattle And Hum

The other stuff's just there and I don't really have a ranking for it.
 
1. PopMart Mexico City - 7 pts :rockon:
1b. PopMart Santiago - my personal fave
2. Elevation Boston - 6 pts
3. Elevation Slane - 5 pts
4. Vertigo Chicago - 4 pts
5. Under a Blood Red Sky - 3 pts
6. ZooTV Sydney - 2 pts
7. Rattle n Hum - 1 pt

I ranked based on how much I enjoy watching them/how often I watch them (not necessarily how "good" they are in terms of the filming or the actual show filmed).
 
1. Zoo Tv Live From Sydney-7
2. Elevation Slane - 6
3. Popmart Live From New Mexico -5
4. Vertigo Chicago -4
5. Elevation Boston -3
6. Rattle & Hum -2
7. Under A Blood Red Sky -1
 
Zoo Tv Live From Sydney - 7
Elevation Slane - 6
Popmart Live From New Mexico - 5
Rattle & Hum - 4
Elevation Boston - 3
Vertigo Chicago - 2
Under a Blood Red Sky - 1
 
Zoo Tv Live From Sydney
Popmart Live From New Mexico
Elevation Slane
Vertigo Chicago
Elevation Boston
Under a Blood Red Sky
Rattle & Hum
 
current results

1. ZooTV - 50
2. Slane - 46
Pop - 46
3. R&H - 30
4. UABRS- 29
5. Boston - 27
6. Vertigo - 23 :eyebrow:

only voting for 2 or 3 screws up the results!
 
JMScoopy said:
only voting for 2 or 3 screws up the results!

Alright, here's a full list for you.

1. Under A Blood Red Sky
2. Rattle And Hum
3. Popmart Mexico
4. Vertigo Chicago
5. ZooTV Sydney
6. Elevation Boston
7. Elevation Slane
 
1. Rattle & Hum- 7
2. Elevation Slane- 6
3. Zoo Tv Live From Sydney- 5
4. Elevation Boston- 4
5. Popmart Live From New Mexico- 3
6. Vertigo Chicagomart- 2
7. Under a Blood Red Sky- 1
 
JMScoopy said:


only voting for 2 or 3 screws up the results!

Average them out. Total the points, but then divide the total by the number of votes. So say ZooTV had a total of 100 and was on 5 lists, it gets 20, and if Vertigo had a total of 40 and was on only 3 lists, it gets 13.

Or, if someone only votes for say 3 of the 7, take the remaining point values (4, 3, 2, 1), add them up, then divide them evenly among the rest of the choices the person didn't vote for.
 
LivLuvAndBootlegMusic said:


Average them out. Total the points, but then divide the total by the number of votes. So say ZooTV had a total of 100 and was on 5 lists, it gets 20, and if Vertigo had a total of 40 and was on only 3 lists, it gets 13.

Or, if someone only votes for say 3 of the 7, take the remaining point values (4, 3, 2, 1), add them up, then divide them evenly among the rest of the choices the person didn't vote for.

:crack:
 
Axver said:


Alright, here's a full list for you.

1. Under A Blood Red Sky
2. Rattle And Hum
3. Popmart Mexico
4. Vertigo Chicago
5. ZooTV Sydney
6. Elevation Boston
7. Elevation Slane

I'm really really curious to hear why you think that.

And for the record:

ZooTV Sydney
Elevation Boston
Rattle and Hum
Popmart Mexico (I haven't seen this, so by default it goes in the middle)
Elevation Slane
Under a Blood Red Sky
Vertigo Chicago
 
tommycharles said:


I'm really really curious to hear why you think that.

OK, here's some elaboration.

1. Under A Blood Red Sky - far and away the best release. Amazing performances of amazing songs, without a weak spot on the entire video. 11 O'clock Tick Tock is a particular high point.
2. Rattle And Hum - like UABRS, it has some amazing performances of amazing songs, though it has a few moments I skip (mainly just ISHFWILF, the Elvis part, and the subpar Watchtower). The great moments are truly great: Exit, Bad, WOWY, SBS, etc.
3. Popmart Mexico - beautifully shot with some quality songs. Proves that the Pop songs really went off live.
4. Vertigo Chicago - three words: The Electric Co. Putting aside all the production concerns, it has a great set and I really enjoy the music.
5. ZooTV Sydney - I'm just not really a ZooTV fan, though this could be interchangeable with #3 and #4 if my mood is right. Very well shot and a few great songs, like Dirty Day and Bullet.
6. Elevation Boston - Nothing special. Hamish's crap shooting on Vertigo Chicago can be overlooked because of some of the great performances, but Bono's voice isn't as good at Boston and the set doesn't have as many high points. Worth watching just for Gone and The Fly, though.
7. Elevation Slane - Doesn't do much for me and the set's weaker than Boston. Last time I watched it, I skipped tracks like crazy and only ended up watching about five songs in full.
 
1.ZooTV Sydney
2.Popmart Mexico City
3.Rattle And Hum
4.Under A Blood Red Sky
5.Elevation Boston
6.Elevation Slane
7.Vertigo Chicago
 
1. ZooTV Sydney
2. Vertigo Chicago
3. Popmart Mexico City
4. Rattle and Hum
5. Under A Blood Red Sky
6. Elevation Boston
7. Elevation Slane
 
1. Zoo TV Sydney
2. Popmart Mexico City
- Vertigo Milan
3. Elevation Slane
4. Vertigo Chicago
5. Elevation Boston
6. Under a blood red sky
7. Rattle and Hum
 
Back
Top Bottom