HTDAAB reviewed in London Evening Standard

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

paulrg

Refugee
Joined
Aug 22, 2002
Messages
1,280
Location
Nomad
The London newspaper Evening Standard has a review of HTDAAB. The front page of their site has the following:

U2 in explosive form

Like the rumble of distant thunder, the rattle and hum of a fast approaching new U2 album can already be heard. The record, How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb, is not released until next month - but we've had a sneak preview. Read our verdict... read

But when I click on the link to read it says you need to be a subscriber. Tried signing up to subscribe on free trial but the mandatory boxes for sex and country etc. did not appear so couldn't.

So is anyone else a subscriber or would someone in London buy the paper?
 
GOT IT HERE!!!

U2 in explosive form
By Adrian Thrills, Daily Mail
15 October 2004
Like the rumble of distant thunder, the rattle and hum of a fast approaching new U2 album can already be heard. The record, How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb, is not released until November 22 and is under the record company's lock and key because of piracy fears.

But the Irish quartet's barnstorming new single, Vertigo, is being played around the clock on the radio and this week went straight to No. 1 in the chart for songs legally downloaded from the internet.

The band themselves suddenly seem to be everywhere, too. The past few weeks have seen frontman Bono make a passionate speech to the Labour Party conference in Brighton, a spate of glossy magazine covers and, now, a troop-rallying one-off playback of the new album for critics and retailers in London. When one throws in the publication later this month (October 28) of U2 Show (an Atlas-sized coffeetable book packed with live photos) and rumours of a world tour that should visit Britain early next summer, it is clear that the group are going to be pretty hard to avoid in the coming months.

The big question, of course, is whether the new album, the band's 11th studio effort, is any good. And while it is difficult to make a definitive judgment at this stage - unless you are the sneaky individual who pilfered guitarist The Edge's copy from a photo-shoot - the initial signs are that the band have delivered another winner.

How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb is the sound of a group playing to its strengths. It avoids the empty experimentation of 1997's disappointing Pop and concentrates on the power, precision and growing subtlety that have sustained the band in the 26 years since they formed at Mount Temple High School in Dublin.

And, while it is hardly the great leap forward that will win a horde of new admirers, that shouldn't concern an outfit whose last album, 2000's All That You Can't Leave Behind, sold 11 million copies.

All the familiar U2 hallmarks are present and correct. The formidable Bono Bellow is unleashed in its full splendour on the anthemic Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own, and the singer's voice sounds broader and more wideranging than on recent albums.

The Edge, meanwhile, makes full use of his special effects pedals, harking back to the shimmering guitars of The Joshua Tree on Crumbs From Your Table and the soulful, bluesrock of Rattle And Hum on All Because Of You.

The album opens with Vertigo and Miracle Drug, two bare-boned rockers that put U2 back in touch with their inner garage band.

The arrangements are then fleshed out as the album develops. City Of Blinding Lights, with its moody piano, is the first track to deviate from the initial, stripped-down template, building slowly into a widescreen U2 epic.

Elsewhere, other numbers also stand out. Love And Peace Or Else is the album's most emphatic political statement. A glam-rock stomp somewhere between Led Zeppelin and Iggy Pop's Nightclubbing, it is a heartfelt plea for tranquillity in the Middle East that makes its point without preaching.

Then, as the frantic early pace finally relents, the record closes with a series of those plaintive, semielectronic ballads that U2 do so well: guitars and strings combine to create a majestic wall of sound on Original Of The Species while One Step Closer, in which Bono sings of being 'hung out to dry in my old clothes', features some electronic wizardry from Brian Eno.

In building their songs up from simple foundations, U2 avoid the bombastic streak that has sometimes spoilt their music in the past.

With bassist Adam Clayton and drummer Larry Mullen Jr rock solid throughout, the robust rhythm twins successfully check any tendency towards over elaboration from their two more celebrated bandmates. The only things that are genuinely long-winded about U2 these days seem to be their album titles, which have certainly become more verbose since Boy, October and War.

As for whether they can still cut it musically, the evidence here suggests that, yes, they still can.

_______________

The first review from the more critical London press is not bad:wink:
 
How many different sounding versions of this album are kicking about?! Miracle Drug is a garage rock track?!!! I don't get how different the interpitation of this record is with different reviewers. I think I'll lay off these previews until I hear the thing myself or a quality review!! I prefered the sound of Music Weeks version of the album!

Thanks for getting the article by the way!
 
Thanks for posting that. :up:

Once again, positive remarks, but I think the more we read of these, the more it shows that one-off listens, with U2 management peeking over your shoulder, are not enough to write a consistent review (something the person who wrote this acknowledges). First impressions are often deceiving, and no self-respecting music journalist will sign is name under a review without having the chance to listen to the material at his own leisure, over a fair amount of time.

If the U2 camp are so paranoid about security that they'll only send out review copies after the album hits the shelves, and keep doing these listening parties instead, we can expect to see proper reviews about 4 weeks after the album comes out.
 
I believe Q have a review next month (that's what they said in this months), so that'll be out by the 5th(ish) of November. So we'll hear a proper review sooner rather than later.

I can't wait, because there's too many mixed signals with the sounds they've made on all the previews. Some say there's elements of Pop and AB, other say it's a return to the first three albums, others telling us it TJT part II. I'm hopeful that Music Weeks preview is the closest as it seemd to sum up what Neil McCormick said about it a while back.
 
Last edited:
It all points to a satisfying album...I haven't noticed (apart from the NME blurb) any of the reviewers singling out any duds on the new album..I like how the second half of the album seems to have strong tracks as well as the first, and the "semi-electronic ballads" will be a nice nod to '90s U2.:up:
 
Miracle Drug garage rock? Give me a break! Just from the short clip I heard I KNOW that's not true. It's not garage rock you dummies...

Ugh.
 
I'm aware that one listen is hard to judge, but I'll take a good review by the London press any day. Imagine if he said, "man, after one listen, these guys are getting too old. It sounds like a remix of ATYCLB." We'd all be discouraged, good news is better than bad :wink:
 
The Evening Standard is a truly cynical rag, I used to read it everyday on the way home from work on the tube...having a good review from them means it must actually cut the glass...I think we're onto a winner folks...this is going to be their best album in years...
 
Back
Top Bottom