ylimeU2 said:
Let me ask you this, Livluv. And we've had arguments in the past and I'm really now trying to start one now. I really am curious. I agree, there is a fine line. I have friends who encourage me to quit, but right now, they don't push to hard. I'm still young and I think they know I will do it when I'm ready. Anyway, what do you think of (and anyone else here) statements like this one:
Or the commercials where a kid is running around licking trashcans. Do you think that's helpful in anyway, or do you think it just serves to piss people off, put their guards up? I know I find a lot of that stuff pretty offensive and unhelpful to the extreme and it certainly doesn't, in any way, encourage me to stop smoking.
No hard feelings (I honestly can't recall any major disagreements we've had in the past).
Anyway, I'm not really sue what that statement means or where it came from, so no comment there. I don't want to get too into detail because I'm not here to preach about smoking. As for commercials, do you mean those TRUTH commercials? I don't really care one way or the other. Most of those commercials are put on by tobacco companies anyway.
Basically, I feel like when it comes to quitting smoking, yes it makes sense for people to get annoyed at ads or random people bitching to them about smoking. However, when it comes from close family or friends, I think that's different. Smoking is dangerous and is an addiction just like alcoholism, heroin, crystal meth, anorexia. How many heroin addicts do you know that could simply make the choice to quit on their own without any tough love? I'm not talking about casual/social smokers, I'm talking about people who have smoked at the very least once a day starting at age 14. The idea that my dad could one day just decide on his own that quitting is the right choice is almost laughable to me. Like most serious addictions, there will come a time when an intervention is necessary. My grandpa refused to cooperate until his fourth heart attack put him in a coma - that was his intervention.
See, it's been my experience (again, with hardcore smoking addicts, not social smokers) that society treats smoking as something that's different than other addictions, something less serious. And not just in terms of the smoker's health, but what a smoking addiction can do to a family, how easily a family can be destroyed. It seems like no one wants to call people out on this, but I think smoking is a very serious addiction. In some ways it can almost be more harmful, emotionally, than some others because society doesn't think it's a big deal, so the smoker doesn't think it's a big deal, but he KNOWS it IS a big deal, so then gets very ashamed, embarrassed, and frustrated because there is this expectation that smoking isn't a big deal and he should just be able to suck it up and quit with little more effort than a shrug.
I hope I'm making sense and I'll stop there because this is probably a topic for another thread. But this is how I feel based on my own personal experiences with people addicted to smoking for 30+ years. Like I said, unfortunately there is a fine line between enabling and harassment and not much room in between. To make it even more difficult, every person is different and needs a customized support system.