dan_smee
ONE love, blood, life
I don’t think calling things the extra songs not promoted through an album or as a single released to radio is a narrow definition for b side.Ironic that you want to have a very narrow definition of what a b-side is, and using the non-USA model as the norm, while at the same time disqualifying Baby You’re a Rich Man, which was only an album track…*checks notes*…in the USA, since Magical Mystery Tour is technically an EP + singles and b-sides, and only put together as an album for the American market.
Your main argument seemed to be that Noel/Oasis are so great, that they have a lot of songs that didn’t even make their albums which are just as good as the “prime time” stuff. I gave you two examples of artists who both preceded and followed them who can make the same claim.
If you want to move the goalposts, whatever.
The point is taken re the Beatles given that was the intention at the time, but it’s been marketed as a standalone album in all markets for 50 years and is always treated as such in remaster campaigns like the stereo and mono boxes released in like 2009.
I feel like citing the Beatles in any musical argument is like playing Top Trumps with one card that beats every other card in every single category. Comparing hockey players to Gretzky, hitters to Ruth, cricketers to Bradman. You tend to have conversations that exclude them because they are incontestably the top of most categories.