Well, I did find an issue with the program my laptop came with. It's Sonic My DVD. I load it up, tell it to import a video file, point it to the file, and it imports it. Everything is exactly how I want (wide screen fit to screen) except that the video file I have is 850MB and when I import it, Sonic says the DVD size is over 11GB!!! Sonic gives you a menu screen that plays a little song and lets you add chapters, but how can 850MB + a few images and one mp3 = 11.3GB? It won't let me select the "fit to DVD" filesize option because I have pay for the deluxe edition. The only option that made the DVD less than 4GB was the "VHS" option. So I made the DVD and everything is exactly what I want as far as screen ratio, chapters, menu, but the video is kinda yucky since it compressed it or something.
I don't get what I'm doing wrong. Is it b/c I start with an avi file, not a ripped DVD?