UNH Hockey Fight Song Banned As Theoretically Racist

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

MrsSpringsteen

Blue Crack Addict
Joined
Nov 30, 2002
Messages
29,276
Location
Edge's beanie closet
Considering the history of the song and what the students from the Black Student Union said, I think they could find several other "pump up" songs that could be used.


SI.com

DURHAM, N.H. (AP) -- Black Betty, a '70s rock song used to rally fans at University of New Hampshire hockey games for perhaps a decade, is no more.

Athletic Director Marty Scarano told the campus newspaper, The New Hampshire, the rollicking, 1977 song by the band Ram Jam was banned because it is "theoretically racist."

The NAACP deemed the Ram Jam version of the old song offensive to black women three decades ago, and UNH has received intermittent complaints about it for years, the Concord Monitor reported Saturday.

Two years ago, a student group that studied diversity at the school said it should be banned. Scarano said a more recent complaint pushed him to outlaw it, but he did say who complained.

Scarano did not return telephone calls seeking comment.

Dominated by repetitive "na-na-na-na-nas," "bam-ba-lams" and the exclamation Black Betty, the song has been played at the starts of the second and third periods of UNH hockey games for more than a decade, according to a school Web site.

UNH plays in Hockey East. Spokesman Noah Smith said the league has received complaints and league members have had "a couple of discussions" with UNH officials and decided the song was "probably inappropriate."

But Smith said Hockey East couldn't force UNH or any other school to stop playing a song.

Student reaction on a campus where hockey is king have ranged from indifferent to angry. "Save Black Betty" T-shirts and banners have appeared at home games and someone has started a Web site called FreeBlackBetty.com.

Freshman Ryan Leach, who formed a similar group on the popular online college site Facebook.com, signed a recent e-mail "Ryan Leach, Save Black Betty Chairman."

"The true fight has not yet been seen," he wrote.

But senior Kelly Vogel said she hadn't heard about the flap until a story appeared in The New Hampshire soon after students returned from winter break Jan. 24. People talked about it for a few days until interest dropped off, she said.

"I haven't seen any rallies or anything," Vogel said.

Most students interviewed said they didn't realize anyone considered the song offensive.

"It's just a pump-up song," sophomore Brittany Clement said. "I never knew about the lyrics because I just associated it with hockey."

Sophomore Matt Connors is head of the Wild-Ice-Cats, the UNH hockey fan club. He said he was disappointed by the ban and plans to propose that the song be played without its lyrics.

But two members of the school's Black Student Union are happy the song is gone. Senior Stefanie Hauck and junior Ola Akinwumi said blacks were considered inferior in the United States when the song was written, and the song has no connection to athletics or hockey.

"If you look at it, basically the whole audience at these games is Caucasian," Hauck said. "For them to be singing a song like Black Betty, it doesn't make sense. It is kind of derogatory."
 
I can see how some black students would find it offensive, having just read the lyrics.

But I can see the side of the hockey fans, too. It's a great pump-up song (especially a great drinking song).
 
lyrics


Whoa, black betty (bam-ba-lam)
Whoa, black betty (bam-ba-lam)
Black betty had a child (bam-ba-lam)
The damn thing gone wild (bam-ba-lam)
She said, "i'm worryin' outta mind" (bam-ba-lam)
The damn thing gone blind (bam-ba-lam)
I said oh, black betty (bam-ba-lam)
Whoa, black betty (bam-ba-lam)

Oh, black betty bam-ba-lam
Whoa, black betty bam-ba-lam
She really gets me high bam-ba-lam
You know that's no lie bam-ba-lam
She's so rock steady bam-ba-lam
And she's always ready bam-ba-lam
Whoa, black betty bam-ba-lam
Whoa, black betty bam-ba-lam

Get It!

Whoa, black betty bam-ba-lam
Whoa, black betty bam-ba-lam
She's from birmingham bam-ba-lam
Way down in alabam' bam-ba-lam
Well, she's shakin' that thing bam-ba-lam
Boy, she makes me sing bam-ba-lam
Whoa, black betty bam-ba-lam
Whoa, black betty bam-ba-lam
 
Is this any worse than some recent music? Some of the objection to rap or hip-hop deal with lyrics - especially as they related to women.
 
"If you look at it, basically the whole audience at these games is Caucasian," Hauck said. "For them to be singing a song like Black Betty, it doesn't make sense. It is kind of derogatory."

Do they not go to hockey games because of the song or because the crowd is caucasian? I guess I don't understand how that is even a relevant point to bring up. I don't think the crowd is there to put down black people, I think they're there to cheer on the Wildcats.
 
randhail said:
"If you look at it, basically the whole audience at these games is Caucasian," Hauck said. "For them to be singing a song like Black Betty, it doesn't make sense. It is kind of derogatory."

Do they not go to hockey games because of the song or because the crowd is caucasian? I guess I don't understand how that is even a relevant point to bring up. I don't think the crowd is there to put down black people, I think they're there to cheer on the Wildcats.

Who gives a damn who's in the audience anyway?
 
nbcrusader said:
Is this any worse than some recent music? Some of the objection to rap or hip-hop deal with lyrics - especially as they related to women.



i think there's a difference between something on the radio, and a school's official "pump up" song -- i'm sorry, if, somehow, a song like, say, "Money For Nothing" were played as a pump-up song and i were in an area of drunk hockey fans and i heard everyone singing, "SEE THE LITTLE FAGGOT WITH THE EARRING AND THE MINK COAT/ YEAH BUDDY THAT'S HIS OWN HAIR/ THAT LITTLE FAGGOT GOT HIS OWN JET AIRPLANE/ THAT LITTLE FAGGOT HE'S A MILLIONAIRE!!!"

i'd feel really, really uncomfortable.

and this is with the knowledge that Mark Knopfler was just repeating a conversation he had heard between two blue collar guys watching MTV and probably meant nothing homophobic by it.

though i would imagine that most people don't know that.
 
I doubt the song was selected as a "pump up" song for its lyrics.


And, I've heard that story about Knopfler. The song makes much more sense with the story.
 
nbcrusader said:
I doubt the song was selected as a "pump up" song for its lyrics.


And, I've heard that story about Knopfler. The song makes much more sense with the story.

I remember this song, and the controversy surrounding it. When the story came out the controversy quieted down.
 
nbcrusader said:
I doubt the song was selected as a "pump up" song for its lyrics.



but i shouldn't be made to feel uncomfortable in a university setting -- which would be my home, which is why universities are different -- due to the lyrics of the pump-up song. i can see how people would feel uncomfortable by those lyrics -- why not change them? i'm sure there are better songs out there anyway ...

:shrug:
 
Irvine511 said:




but i shouldn't be made to feel uncomfortable in a university setting -- which would be my home, which is why universities are different -- due to the lyrics of the pump-up song. i can see how people would feel uncomfortable by those lyrics -- why not change them? i'm sure there are better songs out there anyway ...

:shrug:

The location is a hockey rink, not a dorm hall.


Seems like a battle for a theoretical win.
 
What if they played, for example, that Eminem song Kim-theoretically obviously, because that wouldn't be used at a sporting event. Would people consider that appropriate?
 
nbcrusader said:


The location is a hockey rink, not a dorm hall.


Seems like a battle for a theoretical win.



sorry, but when i'm boarding at college, the entire campus is my "home." it's as much my hockey rink as yours.
 
nbcrusader said:


Sorry, my bad. I wasn't quite sure about your proposed other meaning.



i thought the song was supposed to be ambiguous -- that it could be about a black woman, or heroin, possibly both, perhaps even simultaneously.

sex, drugs, and rock and roll!

;)
 
I never thought the song was particularly about anything. In fact, those are some of the worst lyrics ever written. Maybe the song should have been banned for having crummy lyrics.
 
:hmm: I can't believe no one's mentioned that U2 have played this song, whole or in snippet, numerous times live too.

"Black Betty" is an old Leadbelly song--I think the black students quoted here probably know that, and that's why they're emphasizing the effect of an arena full of white students singing it. When Ram Jam released this song in 1977, the NAACP and CORE called for a boycott of it for similar reasons, although they were well aware of its origins too.

To me, Irvine's point makes the most sense. I'm sure all the white students protesting that they never even thought about the lyrics beyond the "bam-ba-lams" are telling the truth, but I don't think that really addresses the nature of the discomfort that black women might feel hearing the nudge-nudge-wink-wink overtones being giddily picked up on by an arenaful of white people--it was sexist enough coming from Leadbelly frankly, but there is such a long and ugly history of white racist stereotyping of black women as mad-for-it, oversexed molls (nudge nudge, wink wink) informing the listening on top of that.

It's not like they're calling for a total listening ban on the tune, just for it to not get official endorsement as a school "fight" song. I don't really see why that should be a big deal. There are a thousand and one other lunkheaded gladiator themes to chose from out there--why stick with one that has an established history of offending black women?
 
Why not travel the country and find out who else is playing this offensive song and shut them down as well?

You've taken the "theoretical" and turned it into censorship.
 
C'mon, you guys. If black people / Muslims / Haitians are offended by a song / cartoon / abject poverty, they're supposed to "get over it." If white middle-class Christians get offended by something that doesn't even affect them, it's time to crack out constitutional amendments! Post haste!

Melon
 
Back
Top Bottom