I would say that AB is 1st, ATYCLB 2nd and TJT 3rd.
Achtung is perfect from beginning to end.
ATYCLB is front loaded with the hits, but the only real dud comes with Peace on Earth. The rest is fantastic.
TJT is one of the most overrated albums in U2's catalogue. Don't get me wrong. It is a masterpiece but an over-rated masterpiece. It is way too front-loaded. Bullet is weak on the album. Trip through your Wires is a dud. One Tree Hill is average with a cliched chorus. Exit is very weak on the album compared to the live version. MOTD is a great closer, but no better than Grace on ATYCLB. Great album, but not as great as people claim IMO. TJT has great songs, but some of those great songs (Bullet, OTH) did not become great until played live.