What Is U2's Worst Album?

[wertsie]

20 people voted for October?! Oh, well, I forgive ya!

Anyway...I voted for "Best Of" just because I just can't seem to think in terms of "worst" album.

 

[Giant Lemon]

R&H is a mess, it has some great songs on it but it just doesn't work as a cohesive album.

 

[MiniFly]

I just don't like October. It has a good sound, real, well, U2-ey, but it doesn't have any texture to me. I love the other albums, so it's all good!

 

[Mrs. Vedder]

Blargh, I was trying to leave my hatred for the Pop look out of it, but now you've forced me into it. My hatred for Pop definately includes the way he looked at the time and the way he was acting. So it's a complete package, I hated the way he looked, sounded and acted. I HATE POP! I hate the era and everything about it.

So what else is new?

Anyway.....

No votes for Achtung baby!

to all the people who voted the JT!!
And double To Dr. Who for voting and rambling on how overrated JT is! lol

 

[sparkys girl]

This is an edit since I made a lame mistake and was too late to edit.

Okay don't guess too hard, it's Pop. I don't like it. I didn't like it when it was new and I still don't like it at all.

this makes more sense gypsy, the first post had me thinking, she dislikes AB?!

 

[rafmed]

*Wonders who else voted for ATYCLB??*


I hardly find any U2 album as a bad one, maybe I voted for this only because is the only one that has dissapointed me in a way, still it has some brilliant moments.

 

[doctorwho]

And double To Dr. Who for voting and rambling on how overrated JT is! lol

For the last time, I can't help what the albums thought of themselves. Don't your U2 albums have their own thoughts and lives? For example, right now, "Zooropa" is watching a DVD of ZOO TV while "Achtung Baby" is cooking up some burgers. It looks like "Joshua Tree" is telling off poor "Rattle & Hum" about how it's nothing without him, while "October" has locked itself into a closet.

 

[KhanadaRhodes]

*Wonders who else voted for ATYCLB??*

memememememememememememememememememememememememe!!!!

 

[lady lemonade]

*Wonders who else voted for ATYCLB??*
I hardly find any U2 album as a bad one, maybe I voted for this only because is the only one that has dissapointed me in a way, still it has some brilliant moments.

same here

 

[AcrobatMan]

biased comments by doctor who on the POLL

*agrees with DoTheEvolution*

AM

 

[wertsie]

For the last time, I can't help what the albums thought of themselves. Don't your U2 albums have their own thoughts and lives? For example, right now, "Zooropa" is watching a DVD of ZOO TV while "Achtung Baby" is cooking up some burgers. It looks like "Joshua Tree" is telling off poor "Rattle & Hum" about how it's nothing without him, while "October" has locked itself into a closet.

I found your (or, I suppose, THEIR) comments amusing, personally, even though I didn't necessarily agree with all of them.

 

[Lilly]

mr. swallow:

your sig and avatar's will most likely give me nightmares for years.

 

[wertsie]

mr. swallow:

your sig and avatar's will most likely give me nightmares for years.

Ew! Me too!

I remember a couple months ago at school Creed was on TV for something and one of my roomies came over and saw and she was like, "Wow! Scott Stapp really IS hot!"

Um...'Kay, if you consider a guy who looks like a monkey with a broken nose hot...sure...

Sorry, sorry, o/t...Okay...hmmmm....Long live U2!

 

[doctorwho]

I found your (or, I suppose, THEIR) comments amusing, personally, even though I didn't necessarily agree with all of them.

I guess you could make your OWN poll and your albums will form their opinions. But I can't see how. I mean, all JT's feel the same.

 

[Zooropa]

It's hard to say cause they're all good, but I chose October. It's probably the album I listen to the least.

 

[lady lemonade]

Ew! Me too!

I remember a couple months ago at school Creed was on TV for something and one of my roomies came over and saw and she was like, "Wow! Scott Stapp really IS hot!"

Um...'Kay, if you consider a guy who looks like a monkey with a broken nose hot...sure...

Sorry, sorry, o/t...Okay...hmmmm....Long live U2!

Bwhahahahaha

 

[yertle-the-turtle]

*Disclaimer: Vote does not represent opinion*

Achtung looks lonely with zero votes.

 

[christiana]

LOL!! You voted for AB!!

 

[FLYNNTASTIC]

COME ON PEOPLE!!!

WHAT IS WRONG WITH ALL OF YOU!!!!!

well.. WHAT IS WRONG WITH 42% OF YOU!?!?!?!??!?!

October is a fantastic album for it's time!!!!

GLORIA??? Ever see 'Under A Blood Red Sky'???

OCTOBER??? HELLO!?!?!??!! I made my 2nd ever film in film school set to that song... for a reason!! GREAT simplistic piano...

WITH A SHOUT..... such a strong song.....I THREW A BRICK...

this album captures the feel of Ireland in that time....

TOMORROW... so haunting!!!

and all you Larry-lovers... listen to his early drumming skills during REJOICE....

I suggest you people dust off your copies of 'OCTOBER' and set aside a couple hours this weekend to listen to it.... TWICE!

DAMMIT!!!!!!!

....and you people call yourselves fans!

Geesh!

*no, really... I'm not that mad*

 

[wertsie]

COME ON PEOPLE!!!

WHAT IS WRONG WITH ALL OF YOU!!!!!

well.. WHAT IS WRONG WITH 42% OF YOU!?!?!?!??!?!

October is a fantastic album for it's time!!!!

GLORIA??? Ever see 'Under A Blood Red Sky'???

OCTOBER??? HELLO!?!?!??!! I made my 2nd ever film in film school set to that song... for a reason!! GREAT simplistic piano...

WITH A SHOUT..... such a strong song.....I THREW A BRICK...

this album captures the feel of Ireland in that time....

TOMORROW... so haunting!!!

and all you Larry-lovers... listen to his early drumming skills during REJOICE....

I suggest you people dust off your copies of 'OCTOBER' and set aside a couple hours this weekend to listen to it.... TWICE!

DAMMIT!!!!!!!

....and you people call yourselves fans!

Geesh!

*no, really... I'm not that mad*

I know, I know...It's my second-favorite album. I love it! But remember...worst doesn't necessarily mean that people don't like it.

 

[Basstrap]

I love october and I can listen to it all the way through.
I ESPECIALLY like the Tomorrow and Scarlet!!

But it just doesn't give me the same feeling as the others.

 

[wertsie]

Yeah, see...I don't like the negative connotation of "worst." Maybe it should read "your least favorite"? Or, I dunno....Maybe it's fine as-is. What do I know?

 

[madonna's child]

rattle and hum

...though Desire, Heartland, All I Want is You, and a few others are good. But I think it flows poorly because of the mix of live to studio and old to new material.