I wish, predict and suggest that U2 aim for a more commercial sound with the new album. They need to make it more accessible and more of an ear candy than ATYCLB was. U2 have gained momentum already by somewhat getting less edgy with ATYCLB, making the album more catchy and radio-friendly for the fans. I think this should be the new U2 direction.
But being a commercial success doesn't mean that it cannot co-exist with Edge's statements that this will be a more raw and rocking album. To be catchy and ear-candyish, U2 should just avoid slow and boring songs that just plod along like Electrical Storm and Hands That Built America. Then again, I think U2 intentionally inserted these slow songs to strike a balance since a lot of songs in the Best Of 1990-2000 were rockers from Gone, Real Thing, Mysterious Ways, Hold Me Thrill Me, etc.
Let's take Avril Lavigne for example. While her lyrics can't hold a candle to Bono's intricate songwriting (hey she was only 16 when she wrote the songs), her music shows that pop and a rocking raw sound can go together. I think this is the direction U2 should take, to keep up with their lofty commercial expectations and to keep them in the airwaves and relevant.
Cheers,
J
The King Of POP