Song Wars!: One Tree Hill vs. Mysterious Ways!

[discothequeLP]

Arguably the 2 best U2 albums, though these songs can't top the big 2 (One and Streets/WoWY), they can certainly challenge them!


But which one is better?




You know what, I can't decide right now. Both songs are way to good and way too awesome live that..ahh, it's so tough.



Well, you know, she moves in Mysterious Ways!




What do you think?

 

[Axver]

One Tree Hill can't top Streets or WOWY? It topped them a long time ago! It's the most stunningly beautiful, poetic song ever and despite how fun Mysterious Ways is and how great it is live, One Tree Hill wins this by a mile. It's no competition, really.

*loves One Tree Hill*

 

[stagman]

Both songs are so completly different. I'd rather compare Bullet to Acrobat or RTSS to So Cruel or ISHFWILF to Mysterious Ways.
One Tree Hill has no Peer except maybe One or WGRYWH on Achtung Baby.

 

[Salome]

hmm, since in my opinion just about anything on Joshua Tree beats Mysterious Ways I'll go with One Tree Hill


I love One Tree Hill anyways because of its great lyrics
even though it probably lacks a real hook except for the vocal bit of the opening line

 

[U2Kitten]

OTH

 

[Flaming Friar Sr]

yes i loopve both songs but oth is a bit more special

 

[wolfeden]

ouch this is like trying to compare apples and Buicks.

MW is fun and energetic but can't match the emotion of OTH.

 

[Liesje]

OTH wins by default b/c I don't like MW

 

[MrBrau1]

WM only stands a chance live. Even then it falls short of OTH.

 

[babyman]

tough, but i go with one tree hill

 

[najeena]

One Tree Hill is a fine song, but Mysterious Ways gives me the groove I want.