Hi Sicy, a great idea !
YOU TWO BY CANDLELIGHT WITH U2
DISC 1
1. Satellite Of Love (Danny Saber Mix ? Bono and Milla Jovovich duet ? Larry plays drums - Million Dollar Hotel Soundtrack)
2. If You Wear That Velvet Dress (POP)
3. Falling At Your Feet (Bono, Daniel Lanois, and Larry, - Million Dollar Hotel Soundtrack)
4. Grace (ATYCLB)
5. Never Let Me Go (Million Dollar Hotel Soundtrack ? edit out opening narration)
6. Stay (Craig Armstrong?s 2002 Strings Version from As If To Nothing / Bono & The Edge perform)
7. Slow Dancing (acoustic version from the Stay single)
8. In A Little While (ATYCLB)
9. Hallelujah (Bono ? Tower Of Song : A Tribute To Leonard Cohen album)
10. Slug (Passengers album)
11. I?ve Got You Under My Skin (Bono & Frank Sinatra duet from the Stay single)
DISC 2
1. When The Stars Go Blue (Bono and Andrea Corr duet ? The Corrs Live In Dublin)
2. She?s A Mystery Girl (co-written by Bono and The Edge, Bono plays guitar and he is the producer ? Mystery Girl)
3. I Can?t Help Falling In Love (Bono ? Honeymoon In Vegas Soundtrack)
4. Promenade (The Unforgettable Fire)
5. Walk To The Water (The Best of 1980 ? 90 B-Sides)
6. The Ground Beneath Her Feet (U2 and Daniel Lanois - Million Dollar Hotel Soundtrack)
7. Drowning Man (War)
8. Dancing Barefoot (The Best of 1980 ? 90 B-Sides)
9. Luminous Times (The Best of 1980 ? 90 B-Sides)
10. Unchained Melody (The Best of 1980 ? 90 B-Sides)
11. All I Want Is You (The Best of 1980 ? 90)
*Never Let Me Go (I believe the version in the movie / DVD is different)
The last 5 or 6 songs of Disc 2 are moving away from the theme of generally soft, sultry, slow songs for a romantic evening which one may not want to include.
OTHER CONTENDERS
Two Shots Of Happy, One Shot Of Sad (strings background ? If God Will Send His Angels single)
Your Blue Room (Passengers album)
Love Comes Tumbling (from The Best of 1980 ? 90 B-Sides)
One (strings version from the Miss Sarajevo single)
Slow Dancing (U2 with Willie Nelson from If God Will Send His Angels single)
Stay (acoustic version from the Stuck In A Moment single)
Unchained Melody (acoustic live from ZOOTV )
I Can?t Help Falling In Love (live and longer version from ZOOTV)
She?s A Mystery Girl (I believe there is a complete live version by U2 from near the end of the Lovetown Tour)