great article/preview from musicweek

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Larrry

The Fly
Joined
Dec 21, 2000
Messages
56
Location
Salzburg, Austria
Special report: U2 album playback, London
13 October 2004 - 12:03:02


It's the 27th floor of London's Centre Point - one of the city's
tallest structures. Security is tight with the insistence that all
potential recording devices are left in lockers on the ground floor.
The room is decked out like a nightclub with low, red lighting and
speakers mounted in every direction. It's the U2 playback. No
expense spared.

Manager Paul McGuinness introduces the record to a small number
gathered from national press. Tomorrow, the whole affair will be
repeated for regional press and on Thursday, for TV and Radio.

McGuiness starts by talking about the band's label. "It's odd to be
on such good terms with the record company. Of course, there's
always a little pushing and shoving, but it's great to have all the
records in one place and not be squabbling with former labels over
best ofs. The people at Island are the smartest in the business and
the most fascinating thing over the last 25 years is that they
continue to do their best work."

On U2 and the forthcoming album, he says, "The band have become more
and more ambitious. Yes, the albums get longer and longer to make."

He continues, "London is the centre of the musical world, mostly
because of the paranoia it induces and the savage criticism. We are
as scared of that as we always were."

How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb - Preview:

On first listen, this is an entirely different record to 2000's All
That You Can't Leave Behind, in fact, there appears to be no natural
progression between the two. The relative calm, assured and complete
tones of the former album have been usurped by a more consistently
upbeat slab of work. The majority of tracks on HTDAAB swagger with
uptempo melodies and adventurous guitar lines, probably resembling
something more similar to 1997's Pop.

And, as is typical of a U2 album on first listen, the melodies and
song structures are not entirely discernible. No doubt a few plays
will correct that, but for the time being, only Miracle Drug, Love
And Peace Or Else, All Because Of You and Original Of The Species,
are the instantly accessible tracks.

The others: Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own, City Of
Blinding Lights, A Man And A Woman, Crumbs On Your Table, One Step
Closer and Yahweh appear to have almost confused, ramshackle song
structures that demand more patience from the listener. Undoubtedly
these will become the album's masterpieces.

While HTDAAB is standard U2 fodder, it is more appealing that the
band has not settled for a remake of ATYCLB and has instead created
something that could be described as a cacophony of the best in U2
sounds, and how they vary: HTDAAB incorporates shreds of so many
brilliant and familiar moments from the past - Bono's urgent vocals
from War re-surface, the atmospherics of The Unforgettable Fire are
ever-present, the adventure of Achtung, Baby! and the dirty
distortion of Pop all seem to have been wrapped up, dismantled, and
wrapped up again in that intricate bomb that is U2's distinct sound.

Track by track:

Vertigo:
First single. U2 return the glory days of the early 80's when it was
all confidence and style over content. The riff from October's Two
Hearts Beat As One used in the middle eight will excite the most
ardent U2 fans.

Miracle Drug:
Edge digs up the guitar sound that is synonymous with the Joshua
Tree, while the ending has the rousing drums that first appeared on
U2's slight foray into hard rock on Exit. Begins downtempo, but in
true U2 fashion, rouses before too long.

Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own:
Slow ballad that again, invokes sounds more familiar on Joshua
Tree's Where The Streets Have No Name. An honest, heartfelt ballad
that drops rather unexpectedly to a sinister minor key two thirds of
the way in.

Love And Peace Or Else:
Bono and Edge's love of Bowie and Stooges, plus Larry Mullen's
continued Ramones influence is plastered all over this track.
Reminiscent of Mofo on Pop, it flaunts distorted basslines and
dampened drums, yet manages to be simultaneously progressive.

City Of Blinding Lights:
Sounds as though it is a lost track from 20 years ago that could
have appeared on The Unforgettable Fire - this is mainly owed to the
production that seems to have Daniel Lanois written all over it. Not
a particularly obvious song, but one that has the potential to be a
U2 classic.

All Because Of You:
This is undoubtedly one of the most obvious and accessible tracks on
the album. It arrives with a warning bell sound and proceeds to kick
in like Pop's Discoteque. Pure swagger and rock 'n' roll. U2 at
their finest.

A Man And A Woman:
The vocals on this sound as though they were recorded in 1983 for
War. How Bono has managed to pull this off after ageing 20 years is
beyond belief. The combination of this and the acoustic guitar sends
flashbacks of War's Drowing Man, however, the incredibly slick
production serves to remind us that this is, after all, 2004.

Crumbs From Your Table:
Maybe one of the slightly weaker songs, this is modern U2 which is
almost as adventurous as Achtung, Baby! and at times, sounds a
little like Mysterious Ways. The breakdown at the end, however, is
stunning.

One Step Closer:
Very traditional downtempo, atmospheric classic U2 number.

Original Of The Species:
Very accessible, pop melody that isn't too far removed, in some
senses from mid-career Beatles. It's a love ballad that could have
featured on All You Can't Leave Behind.

YahWeh:
Huge chiming guitars, incredibly uptempo song that seems to be
calling out for the ancient Hebrew God.

Fast Cars:
Features arabic style drumming that gives way to marriachi rhythms.
Excellent energetic song and unusual for U2 to complete an album on
an upbeat note.
 
YEESSSSS.....Finally...a follow up to PoP!!!!



I am sooo pumped for this Cd....BRING IT ON!!!!
 
I like this review by far the most! In comparison to the previous ones it just concentrates on the sound of the album - and it seems to sound amazing! Really great stuff! Who knows, maybe our boys have really done another masterpiece! :drool:
 
That's very nice. Another good first impression. But we won't be getting proper reviews until they start sending out advance copies. I mean, listening to the album once, with the band's manager looking over your shoulder isn't enough to write a proper, well thought-out, review.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, c'mon Interscope, or whoever is running this show, start getting those copies out and then maybe someone can leak this thing!! :wink:
 
WOW, Very cool review, sounds a lot more exciting, in terms of sound, than the other reviews seemed to mention!!!

I think we'll be impressed!!!!!!!
 
see now I've heard LAPOE and don't agree with his comments. That's what bothers me about these reviews: they get you to imagine what you think the songs will sound like, but we've got another 5 weeks before we'll hear it.
 
Last edited:
This sounds like a great review, I love that they have mentioned its got a similar feel to Pop and Achtung Baby. Ahhhhh its gonna be a fine album!:wink:
 
Now that break down I like, I really get the all emcompassing feeling in that review, how Neil McCormick spoke about it being a mash of all their previous work. Where as with other previews it felt like it was TJT part II, this has really got my spirits up of how this record is gonna sound. Great preview.
 
Nice to FINALLY hear a description of Yahweh. Good to know that it is uptempo and not another Grace.
 
Larrry said:
On first listen, this is an entirely different record to 2000's All
That You Can't Leave Behind,


The majority of tracks on HTDAAB swagger with
uptempo melodies and adventurous guitar lines, probably resembling
something more similar to 1997's Pop.


Bono's urgent vocals
from War re-surface, the atmospherics of The Unforgettable Fire are
ever-present, the adventure of Achtung, Baby! and the dirty
distortion of Pop


Track by track:


Love And Peace Or Else:
Reminiscent of Mofo on Pop, it flaunts distorted basslines and
dampened drums, yet manages to be simultaneously progressive.


All Because Of You:
It arrives with a warning bell sound and proceeds to kick
in like Pop's Discoteque. Pure swagger and rock 'n' roll. U2 at
their finest.

Crumbs From Your Table:
almost as adventurous as Achtung, Baby! and at times, sounds a
little like Mysterious Ways.

:D :yes: :dance: :bow: :bow: :hyper: :hyper: :applaud: :bow:

:evil:
 
And let's not forget:

Larrry said:

A Man And A Woman:
The vocals on this sound as though they were recorded in 1983 for
War. How Bono has managed to pull this off after ageing 20 years is
beyond belief.
:applaud:
 
Larrry said:
On first listen, this is an entirely different record to 2000's All
That You Can't Leave Behind, in fact, there appears to be no natural progression between the two. The relative calm, assured and complete tones of the former album have been usurped by a more consistently upbeat slab of work. The majority of tracks on HTDAAB swagger with uptempo melodies and adventurous guitar lines, probably resembling something more similar to 1997's Pop.

Thank goodness. I was afraid, despite all the hype, it would be ATYCLB II.

This is the best review so far.

JOFO!! Are you talking about the 'beach' recording of L&PoE? Listening closely to that clip, I do get the feeling there's a hell of a lot more going on there than I can hear. I think what we can hear is just the most dominant sound, like only hearing the bass as a car drives past. Listen closely and I think the reviewers are probably right. I just don't think that clip gives all that much away (which is great).
 
Torture, pure torture.:drool: I think the reviewer does a good job capturing the feel of the music for getting to listen to it probably only once. A proper review will have more comments on lyrics, song structure, etc. There will probably be more first impression articles like this if they are having more listening parties this week.
 
Great review. Best yet IMO. Notice no-one has said anything bad really about any song, in ANY of the reviews! It just can't be done!! This albums gonna be a corker! Can't wait...:drool:
 
StlElevation said:
i so need to hear all because of you

hm... i'm a little worried cause apparently i'm the only one that's not so excited about ABOY. I don't know, guess i didn't like the clip so much...
But the song has a solo, so there's stil hope :wink:
 
With each review this album sounds more and more intriguing.

I wonder if it would be interesting to compare a track-by-track of ATYCLB written around the same time (i.e. before the album's release) and see how these "pre" reviews measure up in light of knowing an album after a few years.

Anyone have a copy of prerelease track by track review of ATYCLB?
 
"Vertigo:
First single. U2 return the glory days of the early 80's when it was
all confidence and style over content. The riff from October's Two
Hearts Beat As One used in the middle eight will excite the most
ardent U2 fans."

"October's"? Maybe this reviewer doesn't know his/her U2 THAT well.

Still, nice to hear almost all of these entertainment writers react positively to first listens. Though yesterday's 11/10 from The Sun was a little too gushy.
 
Other than that Two Hearts being from October comment, I really felt that this was someone who really knew their U2 songs and did their best to describe the new U2 with the old U2 (a style I like most considering I always listen to U2 music).

-Very happy with the overall description that this is not All That... pt.2 (and I LOVE All That...).

-I am just dying to hear these Drowning Man-type vocals on A Man and A Woman. Anyone else?

-The comment concering City of Blinding Lights sounding like it just came out of a lost session 20 years ago on the Unforgettable Fire has me SOOOOO drooling! :drool: :drool: :drool: This is obviously the atmospheric piece. (I am thinking that this is going to be the greatest)

-Yahweh is going to stir my soul, no question.

-Of all the reviews from all these different sources, it has become quite obvious to me that All Because of You is in fact going to be a single.

God! I need this now! :drool:
 
Back
Top Bottom