At the moment I'm leaning towards the super edition. What's the estimated prices for that now? Last I checked it was around $150
That's still a lot of money to pay for a whole bunch of stuff that is already available. I mean, I might buy it too if I can find it cheap enough, but AB, Zooropa, Live in Sydney are all widely available. Three discs out of ten.
Then there are two discs of remixes. I already have most of them, and I'm sure a lot of people do, especially people who they expect to buy this thing. Same with the videos - already available on the Best of dvd. So that's 3 more discs, leaving four.
One is a documentary, which is not yet available on its own but it will be. Three discs left.
1. AB demos, which are unavailable. Very cool!
2. bsides and finished tracks. Half of that is already available to those who want it, and many already have them. The other half is really, really exciting.
3. Mystery dvd. Could be awesome, could be a waste of time. Why are they offering the preorder - and why are people ordering? - when 1/10 is unknown?
Then there's the book. Could be alright, probably won't be too exciting.
Overall, I find this to be a massive waste of money and plastic. Very little of this package is unavailable, yet they bundle that stuff with the boring stuff that's been around for 15-20 years. It would make a lot more sense to release a double disc, or maybe triple, of the album, a disc of demos/finished tracks, and a disc of b-sides and a few good remixes, with the documentary, videos and an unreleased concert on one dvd. And then, if one wants a currated edition of EVERYTHING, there would be an uber edition with everything on it, but for a much lower price. I get that these box sets are common (Station to Station being the most absurd thing ever released by a record company), but there should be more NEW STUFF on it, because it's all pretty boring. Still, I might buy the super edition becasue the vinyl box is stupidly expensive and has an awful track list, and because I don't want to hear the demos in crappy mp3 quality. I will download them first though, to see if they're any good.
So, to people who are preordering: Why? I'm curious.