18 Singles - Live

[mikal]

ok. how about making an 18 Singles Live edition?

with the exception of WITS, every song on 18 has been played live.

please list your best live versions in the same track order as 18. maybe we can even make a if we can all decide on a perfect tracklisting!

thoughts?

 

[CTU2fan]

Should we have rules, like it has to already be officially released, or it can't be officially released, or it has to exist as a soundboard recording? OK, here we go...

01. Beautiful Day - 2001-10-10 Notre Dame (South Bend)
02. ISHFWILF - 1989-12-27 Dublin
03. PTINOL - 1986-06-15 East Rutherford
04. With or Without You - 1989-12-30 Dublin
05. Vertigo - 2004-11-22 Brooklyn (not sure on this one, if someone has a better one I'm cool with that)
06. New Year's Day - 1983-06-05 Red Rocks (Morrison)
07. Mysterious Ways - 1997-08-28 Leeds
08. Stuck - 2005-10-14 New York (any Vertigo version is fine)
09. WTSHNN - 1987-12-19 Tempe
10. Sweetest Thing - 2001-03-24 Miami
11. Sunday Bloody Sunday - 1987-11-08 Denver
12. One - 2000-12-05 New York
13. Desire - 1989-09-27 Sydney
14. Walk On - 2001-10-27 New York
15. Elevation - 2001-09-01 County Meath (Slane)
16. SYCMIOYO - 2005-06-24 Dublin
17. Saints - 2006-09-25 New Orleans
18. WITS - Whenever they finally play it live (how can you release a song supposedly as a single, go on tour, and NOT play it?)

 

[bono_man2002]

18. WITS - Whenever they finally play it live (how can you release a song supposedly as a single, go on tour, and NOT play it?)

Electrical Storm

 

[mikal]

let's try to keep it at really good recordings, at least. i'll post mine when i'm less drunk, but i think it would be cool to come up with something somewhat official, maybe make it an interference bootleg or something!

 

[Joey788]

1. Beautiful Day - Elevation Tour Boston DVD
2. ISHFWILF - Vertigo Milan
3. Pride - Rattle and Hum version
4. WOWY - 1992-08-16 Washington
5. Vertigo - 2006-02-20 Sao Paulo
6. New Year's Day - Slane Castle DVD
7. Mysterious Ways - Zoo TV DVD
8. Stuck - I don't really care for this song live.
9. Streets - Elevation Boston DVD
10. Sweetest Thing - 2001-04-03 Dallas
11. Sunday Bloody Sunday - Rattle and Hum DVD
12. One - Zoo TV DVD
13. Desire - Version from the Zoo TV Special at Yankee Stadium
14. Walk On - Elevation Boston DVD
15. Elevation - Vertigo Chicago DVD or Sao Paulo
16. SYCMIOYO - 2005-10-08 New York City
17. Saints - 2006-09-25 New Orleans

 

[Peterrrrr]

01. Beautiful Day - 2006-10-10 -Sydney

02. ISHFWILF - Rock N Roll Hall Of Fame

03. PTINOL - 1986-06-15 East Rutherford

04. With or Without You - R&H Version

05. Vertigo - Rock N Roll Hall Of Fame

06. New Year's Day - Mexico Popmart(unofficial sounboard - NOT the video or hasta lav vista cd, the in the unoffical sb you can hear Bono's voice much stronger)

07. Mysterious Ways - 1993-08-28 - Dublin

08. Stuck - Conan

09. WTSHNN - 1992-08-30 - Outside broadcast

10. Sweetest Thing - 2001-03-24 Miami

11. Sunday Bloody Sunday - 1986-06-15 - East Rtuherford

12. One - Modena 1995

13. Desire - 1992-08-30 - Outside broadcast

14. Walk On - Grammy 2002

15. Elevation - 2006-02-20

16. SYCMIOYO - 2005-10-03

17. Saints - 2006-09-25 New Orleans

18. WITS - 5th leg Vertigo

 

[Danny Boy]

I think I may actually make myself an "Alternate Version" of U218 Singles as listed on U218.com...


Beautiful Day - Chicago DVD

I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For –Rattle and Hum

Pride (In The Name Of Love) – Slane DVD

With Or Without You - Slane DVD

Vertigo - Chicago DVD

New Year's Day – Point Depot (The Complete U2)

Mysterious Ways - The Ultimatum Remix

Stuck In A Moment You Can't Get Out Of - Boston DVD

Where The Streets Have No Name - Slane DVD

Sweetest Thing - B-side Version

Sunday Bloody Sunday - Chicago DVD.

One - Slane DVD

Desire - Hollywood Remix

Walk On - Chicago DVD

Elevation - Boston DVD

Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own – Chicago DVD.

The Saints Are Coming – Live In New Orleans

U2 vs. Radiohead – Fake Plastic Windows In The Skies

 

[thelaj]

It should be limited to officially released live versions

 

[mikal]

It should be limited to officially released live versions

yeah, i'm actually thinking that too, now that i've slept on it.

 

[Peterrrrr]

I don't think its a good idea for the group to choose their live favorites, they choosed Chicago as the offical Vertigo DVD

 

[Snowlock]

1. BD - ATYCLB Promo Tour - Irving Plaza - 12/5/00
2. ISHFWILF - Popmart - Mexico City - 12/3/97
3. Pride - Rattle & Hum
4. WOWY - Rattle & Hum
5. Vertigo - Vertigo - Chicago - 5/9/05
6. New Years Day - Don't care; all the same to me
7. Mysterious Ways - ZooTV Outside Broadcast- Houston - 10/4/92
8. Stuck - The Conan O'Brien Show 2005 (unsure of date)
9. Streets - Superbowl XXXVI - 2/3/02
10. The Sweetest Thing - Don't know; haven't heard enough live versions for one to stand out.
11. SBS - Elevation Tour - Slane Castle 9/1/01
12. One - ZooTV Outside Broadcast - Houston - 10/4/92
13. Desire - ZooTV Zooropa - Dublin - 8/28/93
14. Walk On - Elevation Tour - Slane Castle 9/1/01
15. Elevation - ATYCLB Promo Tour - Irving Plaza - 12/5/00
16. Sometimes - No preference. All that I've heard are great
17. Saints - definately NOT New Orleans live. That was terrible.

If you can only use officially released versions, for those I had from bootlegs I'd go with:

1. BD - Elevation Boston DVD
7. Mysterious Ways - ZooTV Sydney
8. Stuck - Slane
10. Sweet Thing - Single Version
12. One - Zoo TV Sydney
13. Desire - ZooTV Sydney bonus disk
15. Elevation - Slane
17. Saints - Studio version

 

[BigMacPhisto]

U2:18 - Live DVD

01. Beautiful Day - Elevation Boston '01
02. ISHFWILF - PopMart Mexico City '97
03. Pride - Rattle and Hum '87
04. With or Without You - Rattle and Hum '87
05. Vertigo - Vertigo Milan '05
06. New Year's Day - Under A Blood Red Sky: Live At Red Rocks '83
07. Mysterious Ways - Zoo TV Sydney '93
08. Stuck - U2 Go Home: Live From Slane Castle '01
09. WTSHNN - Elevation: Boston '01
10. Sweetest Thing - some Elevation show
11. Sunday Bloody Sunday - Under A Blood Red Sky: Live From Red Rocks '83
12. One - PopMart: Live From Mexico City '97
13. Desire - PopMart Mexico City '97
14. Walk On - Elevation Boston '01
15. Elevation - U2 Go Home: Live From Slane Castle '01
16. SYCMIOYO - Vertigo Chicago '05
17. Saints - 2006-09-25 New Orleans
18. WITS - ?

Pefect, because like U218, it's another useless repackaging of mostly previously released material.

 

[Roland of Gilead]

1. Beautiful Day (Vertigo Live promo cd)
2. Still Haven't Found... (Milan- Communication cd)
3. Pride (Rattle and Hum)
4. With or Without You (Excerpts from R&H promo cd)
5. Vertigo (Chicago- Communication cd)
6. New Year's Day (Hasta La Vista cd)
7. Mysterious Ways (Irving Plaza promo tour - incredible boot)
8. Stuck (Acoustic B-side - not really live, but feels live)
9. Streets (Slane Mexico promo cd)
10. Sweetest Thing (B-side version, not live)
11. Sunday Bloody Sunday (Under a Blood Red Sky)
12. One (Hasta La Vista cd)
13. Desire (ZooTV Sydney bonus)
14. Walk On (A Tribute to Heroes cd)
15. Elevation (Slane Mexico promo cd)
16. Sometimes... (Under the Brooklyn Bridge itunes)
Two new songs
19. Hidden Track - Bad (WAIA cd)

 

[CTU2fan]

Nice sig Roland. Did you like the end of the Dark Tower, or hate it? Was sort of love/hate for me honestly.

Anyway, back on topic...considering the fact that U2 supposedly have all of their live gigs recorded since 3rd leg of JT, I don't think we need to limit it to officials...though I suppose if we're making it here there would be limitations. I'd like to see different recordings/dates used for each track. As long as it's A-quality soundboard it should be OK.

 

[Blue Room]

Anyway, back on topic...considering the fact that U2 supposedly have all of their live gigs recorded since 3rd leg of JT, I don't think we need to limit it to officials...though I suppose if we're making it here there would be limitations. I'd like to see different recordings/dates used for each track. As long as it's A-quality soundboard it should be OK.

Actually its since the October tour they have been archiving most of the audio of their shows. They started archiving video on the third leg of Joshua Tree due to the Rattle And Hum filming. They started archiving most shows in general on video on the Zoo tour.

 

[J_NP]

B Day - MTV EMA awards
Looking For Any - JT or LT will do for me
Pride - Same
With or Without You - A great LT version or ZooTV Washington
Vertigo - Live 8
New Year's Day - Popmart Mexico
Mysterious Ways - Any Zoo TV version
Stuck - Vertigo Sao Paulo
WTSHNN - Elevation Boston
Sweetest Thing - Any great version
Sunday Bloody Sunday - Red Rocks
One - DEFINITELY POPMART MEXICO
Desire - Rotterdam 10th january 1990
Walk On - Elevation Opening Night
Elevation - Vertigo Sao Paulo
SYCMIOYO - Vertigo Sao Paulo 21.02.06
Saints - New Orleans
18. WITS - Whenever they finally play it live (how can you release a song supposedly as a single, go on tour, and NOT play it?)

 

[Roland of Gilead]

Nice sig Roland. Did you like the end of the Dark Tower, or hate it? Was sort of love/hate for me honestly.

I liked it. Didn't love it as much as the first 4-5 books. I had trouble coming to terms with the end when the series beginning was a big part of my early reading enjoyment as a kid/teen.

Long days and pleasant nights CTU2fan.

 

[mikal]

Actually its since the October tour they have been archiving most of the audio of their shows. They started archiving video on the third leg of Joshua Tree due to the Rattle And Hum filming. They started archiving most shows in general on video on the Zoo tour.

does anyone know any good robbers? i got an idea!