Pinball Wizard
Refugee
Angela Harlem said:Besides which, what some critic says about U2 being the opposite really bears little weight to this thread.
Maybe it is amusing, I don't know, but don't read too much into what the non Radiohead fans say. They're going to be mere observations for the most part. Not anything set to offend.
I think it has a lot of bearing on this thread... I'm not a hardcore fanatic Radiohead fan, but I thought that labelling them as a minor chord/depressing band was very constricting. So, I put in a generalization about U2 that I've heard from a few critics, and many casual music fans. Judging by the reactionary stance of the responses thus far, it seems I've made my point.
Do I subscribe to the belief that U2 are strictly a one-dimensional emotion band? No.
Do I get somewhat disturbed when critics/media/public misinterprets a band for categorization purposes? Yes.
Then, why are some so quick to label Radiohead as one-dimensional in this aspect? The same reasons... the same scripts.
That's all I was trying to say. In that regard, the analogy was appropriate... in my opinion of course.
Last edited: