Blake Boldt with
The 9513 gave it a three star rating, calling it "a promising start" and saying "
Steel Magnolia suffers when the tempo slows. "Just By Being You (Halos and Wings)", a limp romantic ballad, is the worst offender, and the more serious cuts, full of overwrought emotions and overused sentiments, fall flat".
[8] Thom Jurek with
Allmusic gave it a 2½ rating, and largely criticized the sound of the album, saying "Other than a banjo here and a fiddle or pedal steel there, this may be what passes for country music in the 21st century, but simply put, it's '80s-styled pop with different production".
[2]
Sarah Rodman with
The Boston Globe was in favor of the album, saying "On their eponymous debut, the duo known as Steel Magnolia continue their winning ways combining her bluesy bruised angel rasp with his slick, keening country pop tenor".
[3] Matt Bjorke with Roughstock gave the release a four star rating, saying "While
Steel Magnolia may not appeal to fans of the traditionally-minded music; it is nonetheless a solid collection of mainstream country music that introduces a charismatic and dynamic duo ready to become one of country music’s top duos".
[6] Jonathan Keefe with
Slant Magazine was critical of the album, giving it a two star rating.
[7] He referred to the material on the album as "weak" saying "the songs on
Steel Magnolia aren't the least bit noteworthy".
[7]