Favorite R.E.M. album?

[MMP]

Lifes Rich Pageant is much more of a "fan" favorite than Out of Time.

I know a lot of R.E.M. fans, and LRP ranks highly with most of them. And it depends on the age of the fans we're talking about. Reckoning and Fables are liked a lot more by the old school crew.

Well, I guess my list is like that cause most of the people I know which like R.E.M. are my age (17). Most fans of the 90's. Anyway, I'm counting critical recption too. OOT was better recieved that LRP, I guess

 

[lazarus]

Should I not vote in this poll, then? I'm a little confused as to the tiered/rank thing, but completely understand why it's preferable to run a poll like that.

Not unless you're voting for Document.

 

[corianderstem]

For fun, here's how I personally rank the albums:

1. Life's Rich Pageant
2. New Adventures In Hi-Fi

.... okay, I just deleted another 5 slots because I couldn't decide on the order of the rest of them. There's just too much good stuff in their catalogue.

I guess I fail at these kinds of threads.

 

[lazarus]

Can someone just create a "pick 5 favorites" multiple-option poll and see what happens?

Damn my free membership!

 

[LemonMelon]

Can someone just create a "pick 5 favorites" multiple-option poll and see what happens?

Damn my free membership!

I just asked the mods to lock this thread. I'll make the second one when they do.