Popmartijn
Blue Crack Supplier
COBL_04 said:Is Pet Sounds really that good?
Yes!
COBL_04 said:Is Pet Sounds really that good?
Irishteen said:Don't think so, if you exclude flow and atmosphere and all that my ratings would be (Pitchfork style) for some of my favourite albums would be
Funeral - 9.4
Urban Hymns - 9.1
Irishteen said:
I really can't agree with this, I think it has some of the band's weakest singles on it
Louder Than Bombs would be better if it didn't have duplicate versions of some songs on it.gvox said:
It's a compilation of some of their best singles and b-sides, I couldn't disagree with you more. When it hit North America it was massive for Smiths fans. Couple it with Hatful of Hollow and it's the perfect companion, imo.
The voice of reason!u2popmofo said:A "compilation" really can't be considered an "album" anyways, so it shouldn't even be listed.
u2popmofo said:A "compilation" really can't be considered an "album" anyways, so it shouldn't even be listed.
COBL_04 said:What I'm talking about here is an album that you cannot fault. An album that is a joy to listen to every time you throw it on. An album on which you rate every track a 5/5, 10/10, 5 stars, A+, whatever.
Cos I am yet to find one. The closest I have come so far is Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd, which I rate:
Shine on You Crazy Diamond parts I - V 10
Welcome to the Machine 8
Have a Cigar 9
wish you Were Here 10
Shine on You Crazy Diamond parts VI - IX 10
So is there an perfect album for you? If there isn't list what comes closest. I'd like to see what people think
lazarus said:
Also, New Order's Substance is a compilation of singles as well