Well, someone transcribed some details from the Vancouver show on the 9th...which is the reason for the rumor of band members gone, I suppose:
It started playful, but by the end of the exchange, Ryan was being unfair and Catherine seemed upset. She didn't seem impressed by his rantings before this, and after the incident she seemed really upset by it. It happened during Let It Ride. Catherine was playing it in the wrong key. Here's what was said:
-everyone stops playing
-Catherine - chuckles..."What was that?"
-Ryan - "Catherine, how much scotch does it take, really? There's not many rules. One fret makes a difference."
-Catherine - chuckles..."I've got four strings - I don't think I could fuck up again"
-some idiot in the crowd yells out "Freebird!" for the 50th time that night
-inaudible banter between bandmates
-Jon - (trying to take the pressure off Catherine, I'm assuming) "It was meee"
-Ryan - "Ladies and gentlemen, Josh Rouse's new guitar player, Jon Graboff!"
this is where the playfulness ended:
-Catherine - (sounding unimpressed) "But it's ok, apparently I can go fuck myself"
-Ryan - laughs..."It's a free country"
-Ryan - "Well, I don't know...i mean it's not just...it's not my imagination, I don't think anybody was playing the same notes I was, but don't mind me, I just WROTE THE FUCKING SONG!"
crowd boos
-Ryan - "Sorry, I just wrote it, so I kinda know what key it's in...I dunno...that's weird...(looking at Catherine) you might notta been there, though"
crowd boos again
band, looking kinda startled and upset with the whole thing, launch back into a GREAT version of Let It Ride.
~~~